Paul R I, Christoffel K K, Binns H J, Jaffe D M
Dept of Pediatrics, School of Medicine, University of Louisville, KY 40292.
Pediatrics. 1993 Jan;91(1):121-7.
Current recommendations for the management of pediatric foreign body ingestions are based on studies of patients cared for at tertiary care hospitals; they call for aggressive evaluation because of a high incidence of complications. Two hundred forty-four children with suspected foreign body ingestions were prospectively followed to analyze adverse outcomes, ie, procedures, complications, and hospitalizations. Patient enrollment into the study was from three sources: (1) patients who referred themselves to a tertiary pediatric emergency department, (2) patients referred to the same tertiary pediatric emergency department after an initial evaluation by another hospital or physician, and (3) patients who reported their foreign body ingestions to a private pediatric practitioner participating in the study. Most children were well toddlers in normal circumstances, under parent supervision at the time of ingestion. Coins were the most common item ingested (46%). Procedures were done in 53 (24%) of 221 patients and complications occurred in 48 (22%) of 221. Complications were higher in patients referred to the emergency department (63%) than in emergency department self-referred patients (13%) or private practice patients (7%) (chi 2, P < .01). These findings demonstrate the risk of drawing conclusions regarding a universal standard of care from studies involving only hospital-based patients.
目前关于儿童异物摄入管理的建议是基于对三级医院所护理患者的研究;由于并发症发生率高,这些建议要求进行积极评估。对244例疑似异物摄入的儿童进行前瞻性随访,以分析不良后果,即手术、并发症和住院情况。该研究的患者招募来自三个来源:(1)自行前往三级儿科急诊科的患者;(2)在另一家医院或医生进行初步评估后转诊至同一家三级儿科急诊科的患者;(3)向参与该研究的私人儿科医生报告异物摄入情况的患者。大多数儿童在正常情况下是健康的幼儿,摄入异物时处于家长监管之下。硬币是最常摄入的物品(46%)。221例患者中有53例(24%)进行了手术,221例中有48例(22%)出现了并发症。转诊至急诊科的患者并发症发生率(63%)高于急诊科自行就诊患者(13%)或私人诊所患者(7%)(卡方检验,P<0.01)。这些发现表明,仅基于医院患者的研究得出关于普遍护理标准的结论存在风险。