Jordan W P, King S E
Contact Dermatitis. 1977 Feb;3(1):19-26. doi: 10.1111/j.1600-0536.1977.tb03582.x.
Ten chemically different compounds were applied to the skin of the backs of male and female volunteers to induce delayed hypersensitivity responses. The 10 compounds had a low, moderate, high or unknown allergenic potential and were divided among five test panels (modified Draize) consisting of 150 subjects each. In each panel, 75 subjects (mean age 31 years) were always male prisoners (50% Caucasians) and the remaining 75 subjects (greater than 90% Caucasians) were divided, age-matched free males and females (mean age 24 years). Three compounds, each on different panels, had a significantly higher sensitization rate in females than in free males or total males. The remaining compounds produced sensitization, usually in lower numbers, but females dominated in sensitization rates. Viewed as absolute rates of sensitization for the 10 compounds, females were higher on eight test compounds and tied on two when compared to all males. These studies show that females develop significantly more cell-mediated immune responses to some chemical haptenes than men and the data also points to an overall higher rate of haptene recognition. Seven of these 10 compounds were simultaneously tested for their sensitization potential by the modified Maximization method (all males) in order to compare the two tests' ability to disclose potential sensitizers. Female sensitizations on the modified Draize accounted for this test's superiority.
将10种化学性质不同的化合物涂抹在男性和女性志愿者的背部皮肤,以诱导迟发型超敏反应。这10种化合物具有低、中、高或未知的致敏潜力,并被分配到五个测试组(改良Draize试验)中,每个测试组由150名受试者组成。在每个测试组中,75名受试者(平均年龄31岁)始终为男性囚犯(50%为高加索人),其余75名受试者(90%以上为高加索人)为年龄匹配的自由男性和女性(平均年龄24岁)。三种化合物分别在不同的测试组中,在女性中的致敏率显著高于自由男性或所有男性。其余化合物也会引起致敏反应,通常数量较少,但在致敏率上女性占主导。从这10种化合物的绝对致敏率来看,与所有男性相比,女性在8种测试化合物上的致敏率更高,在2种化合物上持平。这些研究表明,女性对某些化学半抗原产生的细胞介导免疫反应明显多于男性,数据还表明女性对半抗原的总体识别率更高。同时,用改良最大化法(所有男性)对其中7种化合物的致敏潜力进行了测试,以比较这两种测试方法揭示潜在致敏剂的能力。改良Draize试验中女性的致敏情况说明了该测试方法的优越性。