Pitman R K, Orr S P
Harvard Medical School, Psychophysiology Laboratory, Manchester, NH 03103.
Bull Am Acad Psychiatry Law. 1993;21(1):37-52.
The validity of the post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) diagnosis is limited by both the illusory objectivity of the traumatic event and the subjectivity of the ensuing syndrome. These limitations are especially problematic in the forensic setting. Psychophysiologic measurements may strengthen PTSD's forensic value by offering a more objective assessment technique for cases that find their way into the courtroom. Based upon the results of published research studies conducted in a range of military and civilian, PTSD and non-PTSD subjects, psychophysiologic data can provide evidence helping to establish or refute the presence of the DSM-III-R PTSD arousal criteria, as well as aid psychiatric experts in estimating the probability of the disorder's presence in a given claimant. Psychophysiologic testing should be viewed as one component of a multimethod forensic psychiatric evaluation for PTSD. It is likely that it will soon be offered and, given current legal standards, admitted as evidence in civil and criminal litigation.
创伤后应激障碍(PTSD)诊断的有效性受到创伤事件虚幻客观性和后续综合征主观性的双重限制。这些限制在法医环境中尤其成问题。心理生理学测量可能会通过为进入法庭的案件提供更客观的评估技术来增强PTSD的法医价值。基于在一系列军事和民用、PTSD和非PTSD受试者中进行的已发表研究结果,心理生理学数据可以提供证据,有助于确立或反驳DSM-III-R PTSD唤醒标准的存在,以及帮助精神病专家估计该障碍在特定索赔人中存在的可能性。心理生理学测试应被视为PTSD多方法法医精神病学评估的一个组成部分。它很可能很快就会被提供,并且根据当前的法律标准,会在民事和刑事诉讼中被接纳为证据。