Keaveny T M, Bartel D L
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Beth Israel Hospital, Boston, MA 02215.
J Orthop Res. 1993 Mar;11(2):272-84. doi: 10.1002/jor.1100110215.
More than 1,300 Austin Moore hemiarthroplasties have been reviewed in the literature, with no reports of fracture of the stem. Many patients with these hip implants had good function. The lack of stem fractures in patients with good functions has not been explained and contrasts with stem fractures that have occurred in patients with cemented prostheses of other designs during the same time. We used three-dimensional finite-element analysis and free-body diagrams to explain the lack of fractures for this device by a description of the probable load-transfer mechanisms between the prosthesis and the bone. Results from our finite-element analysis indicate that, with good calcar-collar support, the stresses in the stem are small because the stem portion of the prosthesis and the bone are uncoupled and, consequently, do not share the resultant bending moment of the head and abductor forces. If the stem is coupled to the bone so that the resultant bending moment is shared, high stresses in the stem are predicted; such stresses are inconsistent with the complete absence of fractures of these prostheses. The results of the finite-element analysis further showed that loss of calcar-collar support with proximal fixation through the fenestrations resulted in high stresses in the stem and stress shielding of the proximal medial cortex. The uncoupled prosthesis also may be modeled with a free-body diagram as a three-force member loaded at the head, stem tip, and in the proximal region. With this model, it can be shown that the reaction force of the stem tip, and thus the peak bending stress in the stem, increases as calcar-collar support is decreased. If there is no calcar-collar support, proximal support must be provided by some combination of integration of bone in the fenestrations and wedging due to the lateral-medial taper of the device. Stresses in the stem are largest when there is no wedging, but high stresses develop in the cancellous bone in the fenestrations. When there is wedging, stresses in the stem can be low, but stresses in the supporting cancellous bone can be high; additional proximal support through the fenestrations substantially reduces these bone stresses. If reduced stresses in the cancellous bone are indicative of a stable device, these mechanisms indicate that fractures of the Austin Moore prosthesis have not occurred in normally loaded hips because load was transferred primarily either through the collar or by wedging, with additional support at the fenestrations.
文献中已对1300多例奥斯汀·摩尔半髋关节置换术进行了回顾,未发现柄部骨折的报道。许多接受这些髋关节植入物的患者功能良好。功能良好的患者未发生柄部骨折的原因尚未得到解释,这与同期其他设计的骨水泥假体患者发生的柄部骨折形成对比。我们使用三维有限元分析和自由体图,通过描述假体与骨之间可能的载荷传递机制,来解释该装置为何未发生骨折。我们的有限元分析结果表明,在小粗隆-颈领支撑良好的情况下,柄部的应力较小,因为假体的柄部与骨未耦合,因此不会分担股骨头和外展肌力量产生的合成弯矩。如果柄部与骨耦合,从而分担合成弯矩,则预计柄部会出现高应力;这种应力与这些假体完全没有骨折的情况不一致。有限元分析结果还表明,通过开窗进行近端固定时小粗隆-颈领支撑丧失会导致柄部出现高应力以及近端内侧皮质的应力遮挡。未耦合的假体也可以用自由体图建模为一个在头部、柄尖和近端区域受载的三力构件。根据这个模型可以看出,随着小粗隆-颈领支撑减少,柄尖的反作用力以及柄部的峰值弯曲应力会增加。如果没有小粗隆-颈领支撑,近端支撑必须通过开窗处骨的整合和由于装置内外侧锥度产生的楔合的某种组合来提供。当没有楔合时,柄部的应力最大,但开窗处的松质骨会出现高应力。当有楔合时,柄部的应力可能较低,但支撑松质骨的应力可能较高;通过开窗提供额外的近端支撑可大幅降低这些骨应力。如果松质骨中降低的应力表明装置稳定,这些机制表明,正常加载的髋关节中未发生奥斯汀·摩尔假体骨折是因为载荷主要通过颈领传递或通过楔合传递,开窗处提供了额外支撑。