Fabian T C, Croce M A, Stewart R M, Pritchard F E, Minard G, Kudsk K A
Department of Surgery, University of Tennessee, Memphis.
Ann Surg. 1993 May;217(5):557-64; discussion 564-5. doi: 10.1097/00000658-199305010-00017.
This study was performed to assess current and potential future application for laparoscopy (DL) in the diagnosis of penetrating and blunt injuries. Efficacy, safety, and cost analyses were performed.
Diagnostic peritoneal lavage (DPL) and computed tomography (CT) have been the mainstays in recent years for diagnosis of equivocal nontherapeutic laparotomy, whereas CT is not helpful for the vast majority of penetrating wounds. DL may be a useful adjunct to fill in these gaps.
Hemodynamically stable patients with equivocal evidence of intraabdominal injury were prospectively entered into the protocol. DL was performed under general anesthesia; patients with wounds penetrating the peritoneum or blunt injury with significant organ injury underwent laparotomy.
Over 19 months, 182 patients (55% stab, 36% GSW, 9% blunt) were studied. No peritoneal penetration was found at DL in 55% of penetrating wounds with 66% of the remainder having therapeutic laparotomy, 17% nontherapeutic laparotomy, and 17% negative laparotomy. Therapeutic laparotomy was performed in 53% of blunt injuries after DL. Tension pneumothorax occurred in one patient and one had an iatrogenic small bowel injury. Charges for DL were $3,325 per patient compared with $3,320 for a similar group undergoing negative laparotomy before this protocol.
DL is a safe modality for trauma. With current technology, DL is most efficacious for evaluation of equivocal penetrating wounds. Significant cost savings would be gained by performance under local anesthesia. Development of miniaturized optics, bowel clamps, retractors, and stapling devices will reduce overall costs and permit some therapeutic applications for laparoscopy in trauma management.
本研究旨在评估腹腔镜检查(DL)在穿透性和钝性损伤诊断中的当前及未来潜在应用。进行了疗效、安全性和成本分析。
近年来,诊断性腹腔灌洗(DPL)和计算机断层扫描(CT)一直是诊断不明确的非治疗性剖腹手术的主要手段,而CT对绝大多数穿透性伤口并无帮助。DL可能是填补这些空白的有用辅助手段。
将血流动力学稳定但腹部损伤证据不明确的患者前瞻性纳入研究方案。DL在全身麻醉下进行;腹膜穿透伤或伴有重要器官损伤的钝性损伤患者接受剖腹手术。
在19个月的时间里,对182例患者(55%为刺伤,36%为枪伤,9%为钝性伤)进行了研究。在55%的穿透性伤口中,DL未发现腹膜穿透,其余66%的患者接受了治疗性剖腹手术,17%接受了非治疗性剖腹手术,17%接受了阴性剖腹手术。DL后,53%的钝性损伤患者接受了治疗性剖腹手术。1例患者发生张力性气胸,1例发生医源性小肠损伤。DL的每位患者费用为3325美元,而在此研究方案实施前,类似的阴性剖腹手术组每位患者费用为3320美元。
DL是一种安全的创伤检查方式。就目前的技术而言,DL对评估不明确的穿透性伤口最为有效。在局部麻醉下进行DL可显著节省成本。小型光学设备、肠钳、牵开器和吻合器的开发将降低总体成本,并使腹腔镜检查在创伤管理中有一些治疗应用。