McCombe A W, Jones A S
Department of Otolaryngology, University of Liverpool.
J Laryngol Otol. 1993 Feb;107(2):130-2. doi: 10.1017/s0022215100122406.
In an effort to establish factors responsible for our post laryngectomy fistulae we reviewed 357 patients who underwent total laryngectomy between 1965 and 1990, for laryngeal carcinoma. Pharyngocutaneous fistulae occurred in 84 cases (23 per cent). There was no difference between the fistula group and the non-fistula group with regard to age, sex, general condition, or tumour differentiation. The only significant, positive association was with previous radical radiotherapy (10 fistulae out of 167 primary laryngectomies (4 per cent) versus 74 fistulae out of 190 salvage laryngectomies (39 per cent)). The median time to occurrence of a fistula was day seven in both groups. However, in the non-radiotherapy group the median duration of the fistula was 28 days; the majority healing spontaneously, with only one patient requiring surgical closure. There were no 'hospital' deaths. In the radiotherapy group the median duration of fistulae was 112 days with 30 patients requiring a total of 66 procedures to achieve closure of the fistula. There were six 'hospital' deaths in this group. We conclude that previous radical radiotherapy strongly predisposes towards the occurrence of a post-laryngectomy fistula. Fistulae in this group tend to be longer lasting and are more likely to require surgical repair.
为了确定导致喉切除术后瘘管形成的因素,我们回顾了1965年至1990年间因喉癌接受全喉切除术的357例患者。咽皮瘘发生在84例患者中(23%)。瘘管组和非瘘管组在年龄、性别、一般状况或肿瘤分化方面没有差异。唯一显著的正相关因素是既往接受过根治性放疗(167例初次喉切除术中出现10例瘘管(4%),而190例挽救性喉切除术中出现74例瘘管(39%))。两组瘘管出现的中位时间均为第7天。然而,在未接受放疗的组中,瘘管的中位持续时间为28天;大多数瘘管自行愈合,只有1例患者需要手术闭合。无“院内”死亡病例。在接受放疗的组中,瘘管的中位持续时间为112天,30例患者共需要66次手术来闭合瘘管。该组有6例“院内”死亡病例。我们得出结论,既往接受根治性放疗是喉切除术后瘘管形成的强烈危险因素。该组的瘘管往往持续时间更长,更有可能需要手术修复。