McEwen B F, Downing K H, Glaeser R M
Laboratory of Cell Regulation, Wadsworth Center, New York State Department of Health, Albany 12201-0509, USA.
Ultramicroscopy. 1995 Oct;60(3):357-73. doi: 10.1016/0304-3991(95)00082-8.
It is commonly assumed that the number of projections required for single-axis tomography precludes its application to most beam-labile specimens. However, Hegerl and Hoppe have pointed out that the total dose required to achieve statistical significance for each voxel of a computed 3D reconstruction is the same as that required to obtain a single 2D image of that isolated voxel, at the same level of statistical significance. Thus a statistically significant 3D image can be computed from statistically insignificant projections, as long as the total dose that is distributed among these projections is high enough that it would have resulted in a statistically significant projection, if applied to only one image. We have tested this critical theorem by simulating the tomographic reconstruction of a realistic 3D model created from an electron micrograph. The simulations verify the basic conclusions of the theorem and extend its validity to the experimentally more realistic conditions of high absorption, signal-dependent noise, varying specimen contrast and missing angular range. Individual projections in the series of fractionated-dose images could be aligned by cross-correlation because they contained significant information derived from the summation of features from different depths in the structure. This latter information is generally not useful for structural interpretation prior to 3D reconstruction, owing to the complexity of most specimens investigated by single-axis tomography. These results demonstrate that it is feasible to use single-axis tomography with soft X-ray and electron microscopy of frozen-hydrated specimens.
人们通常认为,单轴断层扫描所需的投影数量使其无法应用于大多数对电子束敏感的标本。然而,赫格尔和霍佩指出,在相同的统计学显著性水平下,对计算得到的三维重建中的每个体素达到统计学显著性所需的总剂量,与获得该孤立体素的单个二维图像所需的剂量相同。因此,只要分布在这些投影中的总剂量足够高,以至于如果仅应用于一张图像时会产生具有统计学显著性的投影,那么就可以从统计学上不显著的投影中计算出具有统计学显著性的三维图像。我们通过模拟从电子显微照片创建的真实三维模型的断层重建来检验这一关键定理。模拟结果验证了该定理的基本结论,并将其有效性扩展到高吸收、信号相关噪声、标本对比度变化和角度范围缺失等实验上更现实的条件。一系列分剂量图像中的各个投影可以通过互相关进行对齐,因为它们包含了从结构中不同深度的特征总和中获得的重要信息。由于单轴断层扫描所研究的大多数标本的复杂性,后一种信息在三维重建之前通常对结构解释没有用处。这些结果表明,将单轴断层扫描与冷冻水合标本的软X射线和电子显微镜结合使用是可行的。