Goel V
CMAJ. 1995 Dec 15;153(12):1739-41.
Since its introduction 15 years ago extracorporeal shockwave lithotripsy (ESWL) has become a standard treatment for urinary stones. The author comments on the results of Adrian R. Levy and Maurice McGregor's study of the use of ESWL for urinary stones in Quebec (see pages 1729 to 1736 of this issue). The rapid increase in the use of ESWL that occurred in the first 2 years of the study points to the fact that the application of a new technology is often quickly expanded before thorough assessments of effectiveness and safety have been carried out. New technologies also lead to shifts in cost distribution that must be considered in cost analyses. The author argues that continuing research is needed to document the dissemination of new technologies and points to methodologic concerns that should be addressed to make such research as fruitful as possible.
自15年前体外冲击波碎石术(ESWL)问世以来,它已成为治疗尿路结石的标准方法。作者对阿德里安·R·利维(Adrian R. Levy)和莫里斯·麦格雷戈(Maurice McGregor)关于在魁北克使用ESWL治疗尿路结石的研究结果进行了评论(见本期第1729至1736页)。研究头两年ESWL使用量的迅速增加表明,在对有效性和安全性进行全面评估之前,一项新技术的应用往往会迅速扩大。新技术还会导致成本分配的变化,这在成本分析中必须予以考虑。作者认为,需要持续开展研究以记录新技术的传播情况,并指出为使此类研究尽可能富有成效而应解决的方法学问题。