Vennin P, Hecquet B, Marcuzzi I, Demaille M C
Centre Oscar-Lambret, Lille, France.
Bull Cancer. 1995 Sep;82(9):698-704.
The aim of this study was to know the wishes of our patients for information and to compare them with the point of view of our colleagues in a cancer center.
We gave 100 consecutive new patients with breast cancer a questionnaire about their needs. The same questionnaire was given in duplicate to all our colleagues in the cancer center (n = 53) asking: 1) their own needs of information if they had breast cancer 2) how they thought the patients would answer.
Seventy-five percent of the patients and 81% of the doctors returned the questionnaire (28 were men and 15 women; 81% were involved in the management of breast cancer). On one hand, concerning information about the disease and about the treatment, there was no difference between the needs expressed by patients of doctors (as patients). As expected, the two groups wanted to be well informed. On the other hand, there was always a statistically significant difference between the needs expressed by patients and the opinion of doctors who systematically underestimated them. Concerning information to the family, 21% of doctors and only 4% of patients didn't want any information to be given to their family. Interestingly, 67% of the patients thought the decision had to be taken together with the doctor and 56% of the doctors (as patients) wished the decision to be taken by the doctor.
Patients and physicians if they were patients, expressed the same high level need of information, but the patients needs seemed underestimated by the majority of doctors.
本研究旨在了解我们的患者对信息的需求,并将其与癌症中心同事的观点进行比较。
我们连续给100名新确诊的乳腺癌患者发放了一份关于他们需求的问卷。同样的问卷一式两份发给癌症中心的所有同事(n = 53),询问:1)如果他们自己患有乳腺癌,他们对信息的需求 2)他们认为患者会如何回答。
75%的患者和81%的医生返回了问卷(28名男性和15名女性;81%参与乳腺癌的管理)。一方面,关于疾病和治疗的信息,患者(作为患者)和医生表达的需求没有差异。正如预期的那样,两组都希望充分了解信息。另一方面,患者表达的需求与医生的意见之间总是存在统计学上的显著差异,医生总是低估这些需求。关于向家属提供信息,21%的医生和仅4%的患者不希望向家属提供任何信息。有趣的是,67%的患者认为必须与医生共同做出决定,56%的医生(作为患者)希望由医生做出决定。
患者和医生(如果他们是患者)表达了相同程度的对信息的高需求,但大多数医生似乎低估了患者的需求。