Shiloh S, Reznik H, Bat-Miriam-Katznelson M, Goldman B
Department of Psychology, Tel Aviv University, Israel.
Soc Sci Med. 1995 Nov;41(9):1301-10. doi: 10.1016/0277-9536(94)00433-t.
Semi-structured interviews were conducted with 65 Israeli subjects who received genetic counselling while considering marriage to a close relative, 40 subjects married to a close relative who did not receive pre-marital genetic counselling, and 125 controls married to a nonrelative and never having considered marrying a relative. It was found that 72% of the consanguineous couples who received pre-marital genetic counselling proceeded with their plans and married their relative; 86% of them reported that the counselling influenced their final decision to some degree. Counsellees' appraisals of genetic counselling revealed unfulfilled expectations to obtain more definitive answers, and mixed reactions to the nondirective approach applied by the counsellors. Comparisons between consanguineous and control couples revealed different views about consanguinity in general, and genetic risks in particular. Consanguineous couples, unlike controls, perceived consanguinity as an ordinary form of marriage, and had more favorable attitudes towards it. Compared to the noncounselled consanguineous group, consanguineous couples who received pre-marital genetic counselling had fewer children, estimated their genetic risk as lower but its subjective significance as higher, and perceived genetic disorders as more severe. The implications of these results are discussed from both theoretical and practical standpoints.
对65名在考虑与近亲结婚时接受过遗传咨询的以色列受试者、40名与近亲结婚但未接受婚前遗传咨询的受试者以及125名与非近亲结婚且从未考虑过与近亲结婚的对照组进行了半结构化访谈。结果发现,72%接受婚前遗传咨询的近亲夫妇按计划与他们的近亲结婚;其中86%的人报告说咨询在某种程度上影响了他们的最终决定。接受咨询者对遗传咨询的评价显示,他们未实现获得更明确答案的期望,并且对咨询者采用的非指导性方法反应不一。近亲夫妇与对照组之间的比较揭示了对近亲结婚总体上,尤其是对遗传风险的不同看法。与对照组不同,近亲夫妇将近亲结婚视为一种普通的婚姻形式,并且对其态度更为积极。与未接受咨询的近亲组相比,接受婚前遗传咨询的近亲夫妇生育的子女较少,估计他们的遗传风险较低但其主观重要性较高,并且认为遗传疾病更为严重。从理论和实践角度对这些结果的意义进行了讨论。