Chapman K M, Chan M W, Clark C D
University of Illinois, Champaign-Urbana, USA.
J Am Coll Nutr. 1995 Aug;14(4):336-40. doi: 10.1080/07315724.1995.10718518.
Most national dietary studies have reported inadequate calcium (Ca) intake by women, indicating that marketing and educational efforts have not effected dietary behavior changes. The purpose of this study was to identify knowledge, attitudes, and behaviors which influence dairy Ca intake.
A questionnaire was developed to accomplish these objectives, and piloted for clarity and content validity. Dietary Ca intake was assessed using a food frequency questionnaire. After revisions, women were sampled from four sources: a health spa, elderhostel classes, through a Cooperative Extension Service program, and from the Illinois Older Women's League. The response rate was 66.5%.
Mean total reported Ca intake (n = 351) was 591 +/- 355 mg/day. Over 40% of the women reported Ca intakes below 60% of the RDA and could therefore be considered to have deficient intake. Unfortunately, 27.1% of these with deficient intake believed they were meeting the Ca RDA. Significant differences (p < or = 0.01) were found in attitudes and beliefs about dairy Ca when comparing women whose intake was below 60% of the RDA with those whose intake was above 60%. The most commonly mentioned beliefs of the entire sample concerned cholesterol (16.5%), high calories (13.7%) and gastrointestinal discomfort (12.8%).
These findings suggest an important discrepancy between perceived and actual Ca intake which could influence receptiveness to education. Non-dairy Ca rich food sources need to be clarified as does the caloric and cholesterol content of dairy foods.
多数全国性饮食研究报告称女性钙摄入量不足,这表明营销和教育努力并未改变饮食行为。本研究的目的是确定影响乳制品钙摄入量的知识、态度和行为。
设计了一份问卷以实现这些目标,并对其清晰度和内容效度进行了预试验。使用食物频率问卷评估饮食中的钙摄入量。修订后,从四个来源抽取女性样本:一家健康温泉浴场、老年大学课程、通过合作推广服务项目以及伊利诺伊州老年妇女联盟。回复率为66.5%。
报告的平均总钙摄入量(n = 351)为591±355毫克/天。超过40%的女性报告钙摄入量低于推荐膳食摄入量(RDA)的60%,因此可被认为摄入量不足。不幸的是,这些摄入量不足的女性中有27.1%认为自己达到了钙的RDA。将摄入量低于RDA 60%的女性与摄入量高于60%的女性进行比较时,发现她们对乳制品钙的态度和信念存在显著差异(p≤0.01)。整个样本中最常提到的信念涉及胆固醇(16.5%)、高热量(13.7%)和胃肠道不适(12.8%)。
这些发现表明感知到的钙摄入量与实际钙摄入量之间存在重要差异,这可能会影响对教育的接受程度。需要澄清非乳制品的富含钙的食物来源以及乳制品的热量和胆固醇含量。