Kondo T, Ohshima T
Department of Legal Medicine, Kanazawa University Faculty of Medicine, Japan.
Nihon Hoigaku Zasshi. 1995 Dec;49(6):478-83.
Mentally handicapped individuals were involved in some way in 64 (17.7%) of the total of 362 medico-legal autopsy cases during the past 13 years. Among these 64 cases, 32 were suicides committed by mentally handicapped persons (18 males and 14 females). The most common method of suicide was drowning (65.6%). Five cases were homicides suddenly and unexpectedly committed by mentally handicapped persons. In four of the five cases, the victim was a member of the assailant's family; this was considered to be a characteristic of homicides committed by mentally handicapped persons. On the other hand, there was only one case in which a mentally handicapped person was victimized, that of a 34-year-old female with schizophrenia who was strangled by her mother. In 19 cases, infanticide was committed by mentally handicapped mothers ranging in age from 17 to 40 years old; approximately 80% of the infanticide victims were infants of less than 6 months, and this was the age range most at risk of victims. There were two cases involving either double suicide or murder followed by suicide; in one case, the 45-year-old mother of a mentally handicapped 18-year-old son with congenital hydrocephalus set fire to her own house, and both perished in the fire, and in the other, a 65-year-old schizophrenic female fatally stabbed her neighbor, a 68-year-old female, and then she also cut herself fatally. There were three cases in which mentally handicapped individuals died due to freezing, and one in which an epileptic died suddenly due to status epilepticus. In order to prevent these tragic events, at first, it is necessary to much better understand the circumstances of the mentally handicapped individuals and their families without prejudices against them. The authors propose that a more comprehensive psychiatric medical care including the following systems should be established in Japan: 1) Day care for the mentally handicapped person, especially after the discharge as well as during admission, and support for their relatives, 2) Therapeutic drug monitoring to assess the effective level of psychotropic drugs and to suppress the side effects in the patients receiving the psychotropic drugs for a long time.
在过去13年的362例法医尸检案件中,有64例(17.7%)在某种程度上涉及智力障碍者。在这64例案件中,有32例是智力障碍者自杀(18例男性,14例女性)。最常见的自杀方式是溺水(65.6%)。有5例是智力障碍者突然意外实施的杀人行为。在这5例中的4例中,受害者是攻击者的家庭成员;这被认为是智力障碍者实施杀人行为的一个特征。另一方面,只有1例智力障碍者成为受害者,是一名34岁患有精神分裂症的女性被其母亲勒死。在19例中,智力障碍母亲实施了杀婴行为,年龄在17岁至40岁之间;大约80%的杀婴受害者是6个月以下的婴儿,这是受害者最危险的年龄范围。有2例涉及双双自杀或先杀人后自杀的情况;1例中,一名45岁患有先天性脑积水的18岁智力障碍儿子的母亲纵火烧毁自己的房子,两人都在火灾中丧生,另1例中,一名65岁患有精神分裂症的女性将邻居一名68岁女性刺死,然后她自己也自杀身亡。有3例智力障碍者因冻伤死亡,1例癫痫患者因癫痫持续状态突然死亡。为了防止这些悲剧事件,首先,有必要在不歧视他们的情况下更好地了解智力障碍者及其家庭的情况。作者提议在日本建立一个更全面的精神科医疗护理体系,包括以下系统:1)为智力障碍者提供日间护理,特别是在出院后以及住院期间,并为其亲属提供支持;2)治疗药物监测,以评估精神药物的有效水平,并抑制长期接受精神药物治疗患者的副作用。