Miller M E, Welch W P, Welch H G
Urban Institute, Washington, DC, USA.
Med Care. 1996 May;34(5):455-62. doi: 10.1097/00005650-199605000-00007.
Although physicians are all too familiar with the psychologic impact of having multiple responsibilities, the associated impact on practice styles has not been examined systematically. To provide some data on the effects of "work dispersion," we examined the hypothesis that the inpatient resource use of physicians would rise with the number of hospitals in which they work. Data for 1991 from Medicare's National Claims History File were used to profile a sample of attending physicians (n = 33,756) in seven states. The attending physician "profile" was the case mix-adjusted relative value of all physician services (regardless of who delivered them) that were delivered during each patient's hospital stay. Relative value was measured in relative value units, used by Medicare in determining physician payments. The authors then categorized physicians in terms of the number of hospitals to which they admitted patients. Physician profiles were adjusted further to control for geography, physician specialty, and characteristics of the physician's primary (ie, most used) hospital. One third of the physicians in the sample had admissions to more than one hospital. Physicians working in one hospital had inpatient practice profiles 2.1% below the sample mean. Additional hospital affiliations were associated with progressively higher profiles: two hospitals, 2.3% above the mean; three hospitals, 4.5% above; four hospitals, 8.2% above; and five or more hospitals, 11.5% above (all P < 0.01). The practice of medicine in more than one hospital is associated with higher inpatient profiles and shows a dose-response relationship. Physicians and policy makers will need to consider carefully whether there are any associated benefits to justify the increased cost.
尽管医生们对承担多项职责所带来的心理影响再熟悉不过了,但这种情况对医疗方式的相关影响却尚未得到系统研究。为了提供一些关于“工作分散”影响的数据,我们检验了这样一个假设:医生的住院资源使用量会随着他们工作的医院数量增加而上升。利用医疗保险的全国理赔历史档案中1991年的数据,对七个州的一组主治医师样本(n = 33,756)进行了分析。主治医师的“概况”是每位患者住院期间所提供的所有医师服务(无论由谁提供)经病例组合调整后的相对价值。相对价值以相对价值单位衡量,医疗保险在确定医师薪酬时会用到。作者随后根据医生收治患者的医院数量对他们进行了分类。医师概况进一步进行了调整,以控制地理位置、医师专业以及医师主要(即使用最多)医院的特征。样本中有三分之一的医生在不止一家医院有收治患者的情况。在一家医院工作的医生,其住院医疗概况比样本均值低2.1%。额外的医院附属关系与逐渐升高的概况相关:在两家医院工作的,比均值高2.3%;三家医院的,高4.5%;四家医院的,高8.2%;五家或更多医院的,高11.5%(所有P < 0.01)。在不止一家医院行医与更高的住院概况相关,且呈现出剂量反应关系。医生和政策制定者需要仔细考虑是否有任何相关益处能证明成本增加是合理的。