D'Alessandro A, Kuschner W, Wong H, Boushey H A, Blanc P D
Department of Medicine, University of California San Francisco, USA.
Chest. 1996 Feb;109(2):331-7. doi: 10.1378/chest.109.2.331.
Although chlorine gas is a common irritant exposure, little is known about airway responses to chlorine inhalation among persons with baseline airway hyperreactivity. We wished to determine whether such persons manifest an exaggerated response to chlorine compared with normal subjects. We studied 10 subjects, five with and five without airway hyperresponsiveness (HR) after exposure to 1.0 ppm chlorine and five persons, all with HR, to 0.4 ppm chlorine. After 1.0 ppm inhalation, there was a significant (p < 0.05) fall (mean +/- SE) in FEV1 immediately following exposure among normal (-180 +/- 37 mL) and HR subjects (-520 +/- 171 mL). The fall was greater among the HR compared with the normal subjects (p = 0.04). Specific airway resistance (Sraw) increased to a greater degree among the HR group compared with normal subjects (p = 0.04). Among all subjects (n = 10), the proportional change in FEV1 after 1.0 ppm chlorine correlated with baseline reactivity (Spearman rank correlation r = 0.64, p < 0.05). At 24-h follow-up, there were no significant chlorine-related pulmonary function deficits. After 0.4 ppm chlorine inhalation, there was no significant pulmonary function effect. These data indicated that persons with hyperreactive airways manifest an exaggerated airway response to chlorine at 1.0 ppm. This suggests that when large numbers of persons are exposed to chlorine, a susceptible subpopulation may acutely respond with a greater decrement in pulmonary function.
尽管氯气是一种常见的刺激性暴露物质,但对于基线气道高反应性患者吸入氯气后的气道反应却知之甚少。我们希望确定与正常受试者相比,这类患者对氯气的反应是否会更强烈。我们研究了10名受试者,其中5名有气道高反应性(HR),5名无气道高反应性,让他们暴露于1.0 ppm的氯气中,还研究了5名均有气道高反应性的受试者,让他们暴露于0.4 ppm的氯气中。吸入1.0 ppm氯气后,正常受试者(-180±37 mL)和气道高反应性受试者(-520±171 mL)在暴露后即刻FEV1均出现显著下降(p<0.05)。气道高反应性受试者的下降幅度大于正常受试者(p = 0.04)。与正常受试者相比,气道高反应性组的比气道阻力(Sraw)升高幅度更大(p = 0.04)。在所有受试者(n = 10)中,吸入1.0 ppm氯气后FEV1的比例变化与基线反应性相关(Spearman等级相关r = 0.64,p<0.05)。在24小时随访时,没有与氯气相关的显著肺功能缺陷。吸入0.4 ppm氯气后,没有显著的肺功能影响。这些数据表明,气道高反应性患者对1.0 ppm氯气表现出过度的气道反应。这表明,当大量人群暴露于氯气时,一个易感亚群可能会出现更明显的肺功能急性下降。