Giordano P, Drew P J, Taylor D, Duthie G, Lee P W, Monson J R
University of Hull Postgraduate Medical School, United Kingdom.
Dis Colon Rectum. 1996 May;39(5):568-72. doi: 10.1007/BF02058713.
Vaginal fistulas are rare but can cause extremely distressing symptoms for patients and prove difficult to define anatomically. Barium studies have been reported as having a maximum sensitivity of only 34 percent for detection of vaginal fistulas. Vaginography is an alternative method for diagnosis and evaluation of suspected vaginal fistulas, which has been reported to have a sensitivity of 100 percent. We reviewed our total experience of vaginography to fully assess its capabilities.
Twenty-seven patients with clinically suspected vaginal fistulas were investigated with vaginography during a six-year period. Results of vaginograms were compared with final operative or clinical diagnosis and with results of other radiologic investigations.
Vaginography successfully identified 19 of 24 fistulas, giving a sensitivity of 79 percent. In our series, barium enema was only able to identify 9 percent of fistulas arising from the colon.
In this, the largest series of vaginograms, apparent reduction in sensitivity from the 100 percent quoted in earlier series to 79 percent probably represents a more accurate assessment of vaginography as a diagnostic investigation. Even allowing for this reduction, vaginography is still the most sensitive, economic, and informative investigation for identification and delineation of vaginal fistulas. We recommend that vaginography be the initial investigation of choice in patients with clinically suspected vaginal fistulas.
阴道瘘虽罕见,但会给患者带来极其痛苦的症状,且在解剖学上难以明确界定。据报道,钡剂造影检查对阴道瘘的检测最大灵敏度仅为34%。阴道造影术是诊断和评估疑似阴道瘘的另一种方法,据报道其灵敏度为100%。我们回顾了阴道造影术的全部经验,以全面评估其效能。
在六年期间,对27例临床疑似阴道瘘的患者进行了阴道造影检查。将阴道造影结果与最终手术或临床诊断以及其他放射学检查结果进行比较。
阴道造影术成功识别出24例瘘管中的19例,灵敏度为79%。在我们的系列研究中,钡剂灌肠仅能识别出9%的结肠源性瘘管。
在这个最大规模的阴道造影系列研究中,灵敏度从早期系列报道的100%明显降至79%,这可能代表了对阴道造影术作为一种诊断检查更为准确的评估。即便考虑到这种降低,阴道造影术仍是识别和描绘阴道瘘最敏感、经济且信息丰富的检查方法。我们建议,对于临床疑似阴道瘘的患者,阴道造影术应作为首选的初始检查方法。