Survival from locally invasive or widespread neuroblastoma without cytotoxic therapy.

PURPOSE

To test the hypothesis that cytotoxic therapy is not needed at diagnosis to assure the survival of most patients with non-stage 4 neuroblastoma.

METHODS

Patients with non-stage 4 disease received no cytotoxic therapy in the absence of N-myc amplification. The International Neuroblastoma Staging System (INSS) was used.

RESULTS

Of 84 consecutive patients with previously untreated, newly diagnosed neuroblastoma, 31 (37%) had non-stage 4 disease. All 31 patients initially received no cytotoxic therapy because none of them had N-myc amplification. Nine stage 1 patients are relapse-free. This report focuses on the 22 patients with locally invasive or distant disease: two stage 2A with gross residual tumor postsurgery, 11 stage 2B with ipsilateral or midline lymph node involvement, four stage 3, and five stage 4S. Eight of the 22 patients were older than 1 year. Postsurgery, 13 patients had visible residual disease, and two others had markedly increased urinary catecholamine levels for more than 1 year. Recurrent or enlarging tumors regressed spontaneously (n = 2) or were excised 5 to 39 months after diagnosis (n = 4). One of the latter had chromosome 1p deletions (common in poor-risk neuroblastoma) that were not detected in the patient's original tumor resected 23 months earlier--findings consistent with clonal evolution or multifocal disease. The patient received chemotherapy. All 22 patients are alive 24 to 98 months (median, 64) from diagnosis.

CONCLUSION

Our results suggest that non-stage 4 patients without N-myc amplification can be spared cytotoxic therapy because (1) residual postsurgical or recurrent biologically favorable neuroblastoma rarely evolves into lethal stage 4 disease; and (2) neuroblastoma in lymph nodes has no prognostic significance. These findings are remarkable because no other cancer includes subtypes that are curable without therapy to ablate residual disease.