Hayakawa M, Hatano T, Tsuji A, Nakajima F, Ogawa Y
Department of Urology, National Defense Medical College, Saitama, Japan.
Urology. 1996 May;47(5):643-6. doi: 10.1016/s0090-4295(96)00016-7.
To clarify the association between renal cysts and renal cell carcinoma (RCC), we analyzed patient demographics, types of cystic disease, and modes of cyst-tumor coexistence along with the results of cyst puncture.
A total of 507 hospitals provided information regarding clinical experiences with RCC and cyst puncture over a 2-year period.
Renal cysts were identified by preoperative imaging in 223 (4%) of 5721 patients with RCC. Histologic examination revealed cystic RCC in 56 patients (25%) and RCC associated with cystic diseases in 167 (75%). Cystic disease included simple cysts in 72 patients (32%), acquired cystic disease of the kidney (ACDK) in 62 (28%), multilocular renal cysts in 20 (9%), polycystic kidney in 3 (1%), and unspecified or miscellaneous in 10. Cyst puncture performed in 47 (21%) of 223 patients demonstrated bloody fluid in 20 cases and nonbloody fluid in 27. Cytologic analysis of cystic fluid obtained from 37 patients revealed a malignancy in 5 (14%), accounting for 25% of the bloody and 4.8% of nonbloody specimens. Cytology failed to detect RCC in ACDK and multilocular cysts but was positive in cases of cystic RCC and solitary cysts. Four of 5 cytology-positive cases comprised those of tumor in cyst and cyst within tumor.
Simple cysts and ACDK accounted for 60% of the renal cysts associated with RCC. Cystic RCC was involved in 25% of cases. Positive cytology may be expected in select cases, including those with close cyst-tumor relationships and those involving bloody cyst fluid. However, negative cytology does not exclude RCC.
