Mau W, Bornmann M, Weber H, Weidemann H F, Hecker H, Raspe H H
Department of Rheumatology, Medical School of Hannover, Germany.
Br J Rheumatol. 1996 Jul;35(7):652-9. doi: 10.1093/rheumatology/35.7.652.
The objectives of this study are: (a) to determine the occurrence of permanent work disability (PWD) in early rheumatoid arthritis (RA); (b) to identify prognostic groups of patients; (c) to assess the employment rates for these groups over time. Seventy-three gainfully employed consecutive out-patients with early RA (> or = 5 ARA 1958 criteria, disease duration < or = 12 months) at time one (T1) were re-examined at time two (T2) after a mean follow-up of 6 yr (S.D. +/- 2 yr). Potential risk factors, identified at T1, for PWD at T2 were entered in a tree structured survival analysis using RECPAM (RECursive Partition and AMalgamation). Cumulative 3 yr employment rates (3-yrER +/- S.E.M.) were computed from the resulting Kaplan-Meier curves. At T2, PWD occurred in 27 of the 73 patients (37%). The fastest decline in the employment rate was found within the first 3 yr of the disease onset, with a 3-yrER reduced to 73 +/- 5%. The group with the poorest prognosis (n = 14; 3-yrER 14 +/- 9%) was defined by age > or = 50 yr with either ESR > or = 60 mm/h or the combination of modified functional class (1-7) > or = 4 with a disease duration > or = 7 months. An intermediate group (n = 38; 3-yrER 79 +/- 6%) was defined by (a) age > or = 50 yr and low or moderate disease activity, (b) age < 50 yr and more strenuous job-related physical requirements, (c) age < 50 yr and less strenuous work, but joint count > or = 15. No case of PWD occurred in 21 individuals aged < 50 yr with a joint count < 15 and less physically demanding jobs. PWD occurs early in a substantial number of patients with RA. RECPAM defines risk profiles that can readily be applied in actual clinical situations and allow an estimation of the risk of PWD at different time points using the resulting Kaplan-Meier curves.
(a)确定早期类风湿关节炎(RA)患者永久性工作残疾(PWD)的发生率;(b)识别患者的预后分组;(c)评估这些分组随时间推移的就业率。73名在第一时间点(T1)有工作且连续就诊的早期RA门诊患者(符合或≥1958年美国风湿病学会(ARA)标准,病程≤12个月),在平均随访6年(标准差±2年)后的第二时间点(T2)接受了重新检查。将在T1时确定的T2时发生PWD的潜在风险因素纳入使用RECPAM(递归划分与合并)的树状结构生存分析。从所得的Kaplan-Meier曲线计算累积3年就业率(3年就业率±标准误)。在T2时,73名患者中有27名(37%)发生了PWD。在疾病发作的前3年内发现就业率下降最快,3年就业率降至73±5%。预后最差的组(n = 14;3年就业率14±9%)定义为年龄≥50岁且血沉(ESR)≥60 mm/h,或改良功能分级(1 - 7级)≥4且病程≥7个月。中间组(n = 38;3年就业率79±6%)定义为:(a)年龄≥50岁且疾病活动度低或中等;(b)年龄<50岁且与工作相关的体力要求较高;(c)年龄<50岁且工作强度较小,但关节计数≥15。在21名年龄<50岁、关节计数<15且工作体力要求较低的个体中未发生PWD病例。大量RA患者早期即出现PWD。RECPAM定义的风险概况可轻易应用于实际临床情况,并可使用所得的Kaplan-Meier曲线估计不同时间点发生PWD的风险。