Rosenberg M J, Waugh M S, Solomon H M, Lyszkowski A D
Health Decisions, Inc., Chapel Hill, North Carolina 27515, USA.
Contraception. 1996 Mar;53(3):141-6. doi: 10.1016/0010-7824(96)00003-0.
Condoms are one of the oldest form of contraceptive and the best recognized form of protection against sexually transmitted diseases. Their use, however, is limited by both behavioral factors and device-related factors, including complaints about decreased sensitivity and sexual enjoyment. To address these limitations, a male condom made of polyurethane was developed. Polyurethane is a strong impermeable material with good heat transfer characteristics that is less susceptible to deterioration during storage than latex. Because little information is available comparing polyurethane and latex condoms in terms of consumer preferences as well as breakage and slippage, we reviewed four pre-marketing studies of polyurethane condoms, one of which included comparison to latex. No significant differences in slippage and breakage rates between latex and polyurethane condoms were reported in the study that included a latex comparator, and other studies of polyurethane condoms alone resulted in rates in the same range as published for latex condoms. Subjectively, consumers expressed significantly greater preference for the polyurethane condom over latex in regard to appearance, lack of smell, likelihood of slippage, comfort, sensitivity, natural look, natural feel, and overall. While additional testing is needed, these preliminary results suggest that the male polyurethane condom reviewed performed at least as well as latex condoms and is preferred by consumers. If preference translates to greater use, the male polyurethane condom may address important barriers that have been linked with inadequate condom use in the past. These results, however, may not be generalizable to other brands of polyurethane condom currently under development.
避孕套是最古老的避孕方式之一,也是预防性病最广为人知的方式。然而,其使用受到行为因素和与器具相关因素的限制,包括对敏感度降低和性快感的抱怨。为解决这些限制,研发出了一种由聚氨酯制成的男用避孕套。聚氨酯是一种坚固的防渗材料,具有良好的热传递特性,在储存过程中比乳胶更不易变质。由于在消费者偏好以及破损和滑脱方面,比较聚氨酯避孕套和乳胶避孕套的信息很少,我们回顾了四项聚氨酯避孕套的上市前研究,其中一项包括与乳胶的比较。在包含乳胶对照物的研究中,未报告乳胶避孕套和聚氨酯避孕套在滑脱率和破损率上有显著差异,其他仅针对聚氨酯避孕套的研究得出的比率与已公布的乳胶避孕套比率在同一范围内。主观上,消费者在外观、无异味、滑脱可能性、舒适度、敏感度、自然外观、自然触感及整体方面,对聚氨酯避孕套的偏好明显高于乳胶避孕套。虽然还需要进一步测试,但这些初步结果表明,所审查的男用聚氨酯避孕套表现至少与乳胶避孕套一样好,且更受消费者青睐。如果偏好转化为更多使用,男用聚氨酯避孕套可能解决过去与避孕套使用不足相关的重要障碍。然而,这些结果可能不适用于目前正在研发的其他品牌的聚氨酯避孕套。