Greenway F L, Bray G A, Heber D
Department of Medicine, UCLA School of Medicine, Torrance, CA, USA.
Obes Res. 1995 Nov;3 Suppl 4:561S-568S. doi: 10.1002/j.1550-8528.1995.tb00228.x.
The fat on women's thighs is more difficult to mobilize due to increased alpha-2 adrenergic receptor activity induced by estrogen. Lipolysis can be initiated through adipocyte receptor stimulation (beta adrenergic) or inhibition (adenosine or alpha-2 adrenergic) or by inhibition of phosphodiesterase. Since many women desire regional thigh fat loss, a series of clinical trials were initiated using one thigh as a double-blinded control. Trial #1: Five overweight women had injections of isoproterenol at intervals around the thigh three times a week for 4 weeks with diet and walking. Trial #2: Five overweight woman had ointment containing forskolin, yohimbine and aminophylline applied to the thigh five times a week for 4 weeks after hypertonic warm soaks with a diet and walking. Trial #3: Eighteen overweight women were divided into three groups of six and trial #2 was repeated with each agent alone vs. placebo using forskolin, yohimbine or aminophylline in separate ointments. Trial #4: Thirty overweight women had 10% aminophylline ointment applied to the thigh five times a week for 6 weeks with diet and walking. Chemistry panel, theophylline level and patch testing were performed. Trial #5: Twelve women had trial #4 repeated with 2% aminophylline cream without a diet or walking. Trial #6: Trial #5 was repeated with 0.5% aminophylline cream. All trials except yohimbine ointment gave significantly more girth loss from the treated thigh (p < 0.05 to p < 0.001). Chemistry panel showed no toxicity. Theophylline was undetectable and patch testing was negative. We conclude that topical fat reduction for women's thighs can be achieved without diet or exercise.
由于雌激素诱导的α-2肾上腺素能受体活性增加,女性大腿上的脂肪更难被调动。脂肪分解可通过刺激脂肪细胞受体(β肾上腺素能)或抑制(腺苷或α-2肾上腺素能)或抑制磷酸二酯酶来启动。鉴于许多女性希望减少大腿局部脂肪,因此开展了一系列临床试验,以一条大腿作为双盲对照。试验1:5名超重女性每周3次在大腿周围不同部位注射异丙肾上腺素,共4周,同时配合饮食和步行。试验2:5名超重女性在进行高渗温敷后,每周5次在大腿上涂抹含有福斯可林、育亨宾和氨茶碱的药膏,共4周,同时配合饮食和步行。试验3:18名超重女性被分成3组,每组6人,分别单独使用福斯可林、育亨宾或氨茶碱,与安慰剂对比重复试验2,药膏单独使用。试验4:30名超重女性每周5次在大腿上涂抹10%氨茶碱药膏,共6周,同时配合饮食和步行。进行了化学指标检测、茶碱水平检测和斑贴试验。试验5:12名女性在不控制饮食和不进行步行的情况下,重复试验4,使用2%氨茶碱乳膏。试验6:使用0.5%氨茶碱乳膏重复试验5。除育亨宾药膏外,所有试验中治疗侧大腿的围度减少均显著更多(p<0.05至p<0.001)。化学指标检测未显示毒性。未检测到茶碱,斑贴试验为阴性。我们得出结论,女性大腿局部减脂无需控制饮食或进行运动即可实现。