Grayson M S, Newton D A, Whitley T W
Center for Primary Care Education and Research, New York Medical College, USA.
Fam Med. 1996 May;28(5):337-42.
This study compared the knowledge of and attitudes toward primary care in relation to anticipated career choices of first-year medical students at two medical schools that differ significantly in production of primary care physicians.
A cross-sectional survey was conducted at a private, urban school in the Northeast where only a small percentage of students enter family practice residencies and a public, rural school in the Southeast where entry into family practice is among the highest in the country. The survey was conducted during the first semester of medical school.
Ninety-six percent of students correctly identified general internal medicine, general pediatrics, and family practice as primary care fields; 51.8% identified these fields as "specialties." Statistically significant differences were seen between the percentages of students at the two schools who planned careers in primary care, suggesting that selection processes may differ between the two schools. There were no significant differences between students at the two schools in correctly identifying the characteristics of primary care practice. Only minor differences between the schools were found in assessments of the need for or importance of primary care.
Although a significant difference in student interest in becoming primary care physicians was detected at the two schools, a surprising similarity was shown in their knowledge and attitudes about primary care. New attitudinal markers will need to be developed to help admissions committees select students most likely to enter primary care careers.
本研究比较了两所医学院校一年级医学生对初级保健的知识和态度,这两所院校在初级保健医生培养方面存在显著差异,并探讨了这些差异与学生预期职业选择的关系。
在东北部一所私立城市学校和东南部一所公立农村学校进行了横断面调查。在东北部的私立城市学校,只有一小部分学生进入家庭医学住院医师项目;而在东南部的公立农村学校,进入家庭医学领域的学生比例在全国名列前茅。调查在医学院校第一学期进行。
96%的学生正确地将普通内科、普通儿科和家庭医学识别为初级保健领域;51.8%的学生将这些领域视为“专科”。两所学校中计划从事初级保健职业的学生比例存在统计学上的显著差异,这表明两所学校的选拔过程可能有所不同。在正确识别初级保健实践特征方面,两所学校的学生之间没有显著差异。在对初级保健需求或重要性的评估中,两所学校之间仅发现了细微差异。
尽管两所学校的学生在成为初级保健医生的兴趣方面存在显著差异,但他们对初级保健的知识和态度却表现出惊人的相似性。需要开发新的态度指标,以帮助招生委员会挑选最有可能从事初级保健职业的学生。