Nelson T J
NIHS Inc., Ardentown, DE 19810, USA.
Am Ind Hyg Assoc J. 1996 Aug;57(8):735-40. doi: 10.1080/15428119691014594.
The American National Standards Institute (ANSI) standard for respiratory protection (ANSI Z88.2 1992) lists assigned protection factors (APFs) for various respirators. The committee that developed the APFs based its decisions on a review of available studies of respirator performance. If workplace studies were available, these formed the basis for the number assigned. If no such studies were available, then laboratory studies, design analogies, and other information were used to decide what value to assign. For half-mask air purifying respirators, four workplace protection factor studies were consulted to arrive at an APF. For loose-fitting facepiece powered air purifying respirators (PAPRs), five workplace studies and two laboratory studies were reviewed. For full-face air purifying, helmet/hooded PAPRs, and most supplied air respirators no workplace studies were available. The APF was based on laboratory studies or decided by analogy to other equipment. For the remaining respirators only single workplace protection factor studies were available, and these were used by the committee to assign an APF. The database available to the ANSI committee was limited. Most of the studies available for review were not published. The committee in a sense was required to perform peer review on the information to use the data. Studies completed after the ANSI committee finished its deliberations, when added to the data used, continue to support the APFs assigned by ANSI.
美国国家标准学会(ANSI)的呼吸防护标准(ANSI Z88.2 1992)列出了各种呼吸器的指定防护因数(APF)。制定APF的委员会是在对呼吸器性能的现有研究进行审查的基础上做出决定的。如果有工作场所研究,这些研究就构成了所指定数字的基础。如果没有此类研究,那么就使用实验室研究、设计类比和其他信息来决定赋予什么值。对于半面罩空气净化呼吸器,参考了四项工作场所防护因数研究来得出一个APF。对于宽松面罩动力空气净化呼吸器(PAPR),审查了五项工作场所研究和两项实验室研究。对于全面罩空气净化呼吸器、头盔/头罩式PAPR以及大多数供气式呼吸器,没有可用的工作场所研究。APF是基于实验室研究或通过与其他设备类比来确定的。对于其余的呼吸器,只有单项工作场所防护因数研究可用,委员会利用这些研究来指定一个APF。ANSI委员会可用的数据库是有限的。可供审查的大多数研究都未发表。从某种意义上说,委员会需要对这些信息进行同行评审以使用这些数据。在ANSI委员会完成审议后完成的研究,在添加到所使用的数据中时,继续支持ANSI指定的APF。