de Mol van Otterloo J J, Tuinzing D B, Kostense P
Department of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery, Free University Hospital, Amsterdam, The Netherlands.
J Craniomaxillofac Surg. 1996 Apr;24(2):69-77. doi: 10.1016/s1010-5182(96)80015-1.
In 25 patients with vertical maxillary deficiency, selected for a group of 410 Le Fort I osteotomies, the anterior part of the maxilla was repositioned inferiorly. Four groups could be distinguished. A group (n = 6) with downgrafting of the maxilla alone, fixed with wire osteosynthesis, a group (n = 6) treated with Le Fort I and sagittal split osteotomy with a wire-fixed maxilla, a group (n = 8) with a Le Fort I and vertical ramus osteotomy where the maxilla was fixed with wire and group (n = 5) treated by Le Fort I and vertical ramus osteotomy in which the maxilla had been fixed with miniplate osteosynthesis. In the group of single maxilla repositioning and in bimaxillary group with a plate-fixed maxilla, the range of relapse was -0.3 mm to +1.0 mm (mean + 0.4 mm) and 0 mm to + 1.0 mm (mean + 0.5 mm) respectively, which was not correlated to the distance of inferior repositioning. The bimaxillary cases, in which the maxilla had wire osteosynthesis, showed postoperative relapse ranging from - 1.4 mm to + 3.4 mm (mean + 1.3 mm) (sagittal split osteotomy) and - 1.1 mm to + 3.7 mm (mean + 1.2 mm) (vertical ramus osteotomy). In these cases the outcome of surgical intervention appeared completely unpredictable. If these figures are presented as percentages as is done in the literature in the majority of publications, a misleading impression appears. Likewise information about operation technique, fixation methods and linear measurements of movement and relapse (instead of percentages) are essential in comparing different studies.
在因410例勒福Ⅰ型截骨术而入选的25例垂直上颌骨发育不足患者中,上颌前部被向下重新定位。可分为四组。一组(n = 6)仅进行上颌骨下移植骨,采用钢丝骨固定术;一组(n = 6)采用勒福Ⅰ型截骨术和矢状劈开截骨术,上颌骨用钢丝固定;一组(n = 8)采用勒福Ⅰ型截骨术和垂直升支截骨术,上颌骨用钢丝固定;一组(n = 5)采用勒福Ⅰ型截骨术和垂直升支截骨术,上颌骨用微型钢板骨固定术。在单纯上颌骨重新定位组和采用钢板固定上颌骨的双颌手术组中,复发范围分别为-0.3毫米至+1.0毫米(平均+0.4毫米)和0毫米至+1.0毫米(平均+0.5毫米),这与向下重新定位的距离无关。上颌骨采用钢丝骨固定术的双颌手术病例,术后复发范围为-1.4毫米至+3.4毫米(平均+1.3毫米)(矢状劈开截骨术)和-1.1毫米至+3.7毫米(平均+1.2毫米)(垂直升支截骨术)。在这些病例中,手术干预的结果似乎完全不可预测。如果像大多数文献那样将这些数据以百分比形式呈现,就会产生误导性印象。同样,关于手术技术、固定方法以及移动和复发的线性测量(而非百分比)的信息对于比较不同研究至关重要。