Bull World Health Organ. 1996;74(3):253-68.
To assess an immunization schedule combining oral (OPV) and inactivated poliovirus vaccines (IPV), we conducted a clinical trial in the Gambia, Oman, and Thailand. Children were randomized to receive one of the following schedules: OPV at birth, 6, 10, and 14 weeks of age; OPV at birth followed by both OPV and IPV at 6, 10, and 14 weeks of age: or placebo at birth followed by IPV at 6, 10, and 14 weeks of age. A total of 1685 infants were enrolled; 24-week serum specimens were available for 1291 infants (77%). Across the study sites at 24 weeks of age, the proportion of seropositive children in the combined schedule group was 95-99% for type 1, 99-100% for type 2, and 97-100% for type 3. In the Gambia and Oman, the combined schedule performed significantly better than OPV for type 1 (95-97% versus 88-90%) and type 3 (97-99% versus 72-73%). In the Gambia and Oman, seroprevalences in the IPV group were lower for type 1 (significantly lower in the Gambia); significantly lower for type 2; and significantly higher for type 3, compared with the OPV group. In Thailand, the IPV group had significantly lower proportions of children who were seropositive for each of the three types, compared with the OPV group. The responses to OPV in the Gambia, Oman, and Thailand were consistent with previous studies from these countries. IPV given at 6, 10, and 14 weeks of age provided inadequate serological protection against poliovirus, especially type 1. The combined schedule provided the highest levels of serum antibody response, with mucosal immunity equivalent to that produced by OPV alone.
为评估口服脊髓灰质炎疫苗(OPV)和灭活脊髓灰质炎病毒疫苗(IPV)联合免疫程序,我们在冈比亚、阿曼和泰国开展了一项临床试验。儿童被随机分配接受以下免疫程序之一:出生时、6周龄、10周龄和14周龄时接种OPV;出生时接种OPV,随后在6周龄、10周龄和14周龄时同时接种OPV和IPV;或出生时接种安慰剂,随后在6周龄、10周龄和14周龄时接种IPV。共纳入1685名婴儿;1291名婴儿(77%)有24周龄时的血清样本。在24周龄时,各研究地点联合免疫程序组中1型血清阳性儿童比例为95 - 99%,2型为99 - 100%,3型为97 - 100%。在冈比亚和阿曼,联合免疫程序对1型(95 - 97%对88 - 90%)和3型(97 - 99%对72 - 73%)的效果显著优于OPV。在冈比亚和阿曼,与OPV组相比,IPV组1型血清阳性率较低(在冈比亚显著更低);2型显著更低;3型显著更高。在泰国,与OPV组相比,IPV组三种类型血清阳性儿童的比例均显著更低。冈比亚、阿曼和泰国对OPV的反应与这些国家之前的研究一致。6周龄、10周龄和14周龄时接种IPV提供的针对脊髓灰质炎病毒的血清学保护不足,尤其是对1型。联合免疫程序产生了最高水平的血清抗体反应,黏膜免疫等同于单独接种OPV产生的免疫。