Santos A A, Wilmore D W
Department of Surgery, Harvard University, Brigham and Women's Hospital, Boston, Massachusetts 02115, USA.
Shock. 1996;6 Suppl 1:S50-6.
Improvements in detection of cytokines and other intermediary substances has allowed a new wave of investigations to determine the role that endotoxin plays in initiating these mediators. We have reviewed all studies of endotoxin administration (Escherichia coli, Lot EC-5, 4 ng/kg) to healthy humans in an effort to collate the currently available data that describes mediator elaboration and therapy directed against them. More than 60 studies included descriptions of the effects of administering endotoxin alone and with pretreatments, such as antiendotoxin molecules (n = 8), mediator receptor antagonist (n = 9), antimediator therapy (n = 5), and anti-inflammatory agents (n = 49), which were given in an attempt to modify the inflammatory response. Endpoints that were monitored included vital signs and symptoms, leukocyte and platelet patterns, alterations in coagulation, hormonal secretion, plasma enzyme activities, plasma cytokine and anticytokine concentrations, plasma metabolic substrates, and ex vivo mononuclear cell responses. Analysis of investigations of human endotoxemia with and without pretreatments suggests that such trials a) are safe, b) are unable to achieve the success of small animal studies using pretreatments of endotoxemia, and c) have results similar to antimediator therapy administered recently to patients with Gram-negative bacteremia. Establishment of endotoxemia in humans may provide a valuable screening method to determine which antimediator treatments should be submitted to carefully constructed clinical trials.
细胞因子和其他中间物质检测方法的改进,使得新一轮研究得以开展,以确定内毒素在引发这些介质过程中所起的作用。我们回顾了所有针对健康人类注射内毒素(大肠杆菌,批次EC - 5,4 ng/kg)的研究,旨在整理目前可获得的关于介质释放以及针对这些介质的治疗的数据。60多项研究包括了单独注射内毒素以及进行预处理(如抗内毒素分子,n = 8;介质受体拮抗剂,n = 9;抗介质治疗,n = 5;抗炎药物,n = 49)后效果的描述,进行这些预处理是为了改变炎症反应。监测的终点包括生命体征和症状、白细胞和血小板模式、凝血改变、激素分泌、血浆酶活性、血浆细胞因子和抗细胞因子浓度、血浆代谢底物以及体外单核细胞反应。对有无预处理的人类内毒素血症研究分析表明,此类试验:a)是安全的;b)无法取得使用内毒素血症预处理的小动物研究那样的成功;c)其结果与最近用于革兰氏阴性菌血症患者的抗介质治疗相似。在人类中建立内毒素血症可能提供一种有价值的筛选方法,以确定哪些抗介质治疗应提交精心设计的临床试验。