Zhang J, Bowes W A, Grey T W, McMahon M J
Family Health International, Research Triangle Park, North Carolina, USA.
Obstet Gynecol. 1996 Oct;88(4 Pt 1):593-8. doi: 10.1016/0029-7844(96)00269-4.
To examine the effect of mode of delivery on twin survival, especially among very premature twin births, in a population-based historical cohort study.
A total of 4428 pairs of live-born twins, birth weight 500 g or greater, were included based on data from vital records of the entire state of North Carolina for the period 1988-1991. The main outcome measures were Apgar score at 5 minutes (less than 7 versus 7 or greater), neonatal death, and infant death.
After controlling for birth weight, twin order, fetal presentation, ethnicity, maternal age, marital status, and adequacy of prenatal care, we found that cesarean delivery was associated with reduced risks (by 50-60%) of low 5-minute Apgar score and neonatal and infant deaths among infants born weighing 500-749 g (P < .05). The cesarean delivery benefited the second twins more than the first twins. Among infants weighing more than 1000 g, the mode of delivery was not associated with either low Apgar score or neonatal and infant mortality.
Our study suggests that cesarean delivery for twins with estimated fetal weights less than 1000 g together with a more liberal use of vaginal delivery for twins with estimated fetal weights more than 1000 g would have a net effect of increasing perinatal survival while lowering the overall cesarean delivery rate.
在一项基于人群的历史性队列研究中,探讨分娩方式对双胎存活的影响,尤其是极早产双胎分娩的情况。
基于北卡罗来纳州全州1988 - 1991年生命记录数据,纳入了4428对出生体重500克及以上的活产双胎。主要结局指标为5分钟阿氏评分(小于7分与7分及以上)、新生儿死亡和婴儿死亡。
在对出生体重、双胎顺序、胎儿先露部位、种族、产妇年龄、婚姻状况和产前护理充分性进行控制后,我们发现剖宫产与出生体重500 - 749克婴儿的低5分钟阿氏评分、新生儿及婴儿死亡风险降低(降低50 - 60%)相关(P < .05)。剖宫产对第二个胎儿的益处大于第一个胎儿。在体重超过1000克的婴儿中,分娩方式与低阿氏评分或新生儿及婴儿死亡率均无关。
我们的研究表明,对于估计胎儿体重小于1000克的双胎行剖宫产,同时对估计胎儿体重大于1000克的双胎更广泛地采用阴道分娩,将产生增加围产期存活率同时降低总体剖宫产率的净效应。