Eddy T J, Gallup G G, Povinelli D J
New Iberia Research Center, University of Southwestern Louisiana 70560, USA.
J Comp Psychol. 1996 Mar;110(1):38-44. doi: 10.1037/0735-7036.110.1.38.
To evaluate Heyes's (1994) claim that chimpanzees are incapable of using mirrored information to obtain otherwise unavailable information about the self, we exposed two different age groups of chimpanzees (3-year-olds and 7- to 10-year-olds) to mirrors and video images of conspecifics. Their reactions to these stimuli were videotaped and were later scored for behavioral indices of self-recognition by a trained observer who was blind to the purpose and conditions of the study. Some types of behavior (contingent facial and body movements) were clearly influenced by the type of stimulus that the chimpanzees were viewing but not by age; however, other behaviors (self-exploration) were affected by age in conjunction with the type of stimulus the animals were viewing. The results suggest that, unlike self-exploratory behavior, contingent facial and body movements may not, by themselves, be reliable indicators of self-recognition.
为了评估海耶斯(1994年)提出的黑猩猩无法利用镜子信息来获取关于自身其他方式无法获得的信息这一说法,我们让两组不同年龄的黑猩猩(3岁和7至10岁)接触镜子和同种个体的视频图像。它们对这些刺激的反应被录像,随后由一位对研究目的和条件不知情的训练有素的观察者根据自我识别行为指标进行评分。某些行为类型(伴随的面部和身体动作)明显受到黑猩猩所观看刺激类型的影响,而非年龄;然而,其他行为(自我探索)则受到年龄以及动物所观看刺激类型的共同影响。结果表明,与自我探索行为不同,伴随的面部和身体动作本身可能并非自我识别的可靠指标。