Hanajima R, Ugawa Y, Terao Y, Ogata K, Kanazawa I
Department of Neurology, School of Medicine, University of Tokyo, Japan.
J Neurol Sci. 1996 Sep 1;140(1-2):109-16. doi: 10.1016/0022-510x(96)00100-1.
We used a paired-pulse magnetic stimulation technique to study ipsilateral cortico-cortical inhibition of the motor cortex in 48 patients with various neurological disorders and in 20 normal volunteers. In the normal subjects, the first subthreshold conditioning stimulus suppressed responses to the second suprathreshold test stimulus at interstimulus intervals (ISIs) of 1-5 ms (inhibition at short intervals), and facilitated them at ISIs of 8-15 ms (facilitation at long intervals). Patients with motor neuron disease, except those in whom brain stimulation produced control responses that were generated by direct activation of corticospinal neurons (D-waves), had normal inhibition at short intervals. Facilitation at long intervals was not elicited in some patients with amyotrophic lateral sclerosis. Less inhibition at short intervals and normal facilitation at long intervals was found for all the patients with progressive myoclonic epilepsy, a condition in which the excitability of cortical inhibitory interneurons is thought to be affected. Inhibition at short intervals was disturbed, but facilitation at long intervals was intact in the patients with movement disorders (Parkinson's disease, corticobasal degeneration, and Wilson's disease). In these patients, positron emission tomography (PET) studies showed decreased regional cerebral blood flow (rCBF) in the basal ganglia in the relaxed state. However, normal suppression was elicited in the patients with Parkinson's disease with normal rCBF. In four patients with chorea, the time-course of inhibition and facilitation was normal, even though PET studies showed decreased rCBF in the basal ganglia in two of them. Normal inhibition could not be elicited in patients who had a small lesion in the basal ganglia or in the pathway from basal ganglia to the primary motor cortex; the putamen, globus pallidus, and supplementary motor cortex. In contrast, patients who had a lesion in a sensory system (sensory cortex or sensory thalamus) or in the pontine nucleus had normal suppression. We conclude that the results of ipsilateral cortico-cortical inhibition with paired magnetic stimulation reflect the excitability of inhibitory interneurons in the motor cortex and that outputs from the basal ganglia markedly affect this inhibition, but outputs from somato-sensory systems or cerebellum do not. Moreover, dysfunction of the corticospinal tract or spinal motoneurons does not affect results obtained by the paired magnetic stimulation technique when the control responses are generated by I-waves (i.e. descending volleys are produced by transsynaptic activation of the corticospinal tract neurons.
我们采用配对脉冲磁刺激技术,对48例患有各种神经系统疾病的患者以及20名正常志愿者的运动皮质同侧皮质-皮质抑制进行了研究。在正常受试者中,第一个阈下条件刺激在1 - 5毫秒的刺激间隔(ISIs)下抑制了对第二个阈上测试刺激的反应(短间隔抑制),而在8 - 15毫秒的刺激间隔下则促进了反应(长间隔促进)。运动神经元病患者,除了那些脑刺激产生由皮质脊髓神经元直接激活所产生的对照反应(D波)的患者外,在短间隔时具有正常抑制。一些肌萎缩侧索硬化患者未引出长间隔促进。在所有进行性肌阵挛癫痫患者中发现短间隔抑制减少而长间隔促进正常,在这种疾病中,皮质抑制性中间神经元的兴奋性被认为受到影响。在运动障碍患者(帕金森病、皮质基底节变性和威尔逊病)中,短间隔抑制受到干扰,但长间隔促进完好无损。在这些患者中,正电子发射断层扫描(PET)研究显示在放松状态下基底节区域脑血流(rCBF)减少。然而,rCBF正常的帕金森病患者引出了正常抑制。在4例舞蹈病患者中,抑制和促进的时间进程正常,尽管PET研究显示其中2例患者的基底节rCBF减少。在基底节或从基底节到初级运动皮质的通路(壳核、苍白球和辅助运动皮质)有小病变的患者中无法引出正常抑制。相反,在感觉系统(感觉皮质或感觉丘脑)或脑桥核有病变的患者中具有正常抑制。我们得出结论,配对磁刺激的同侧皮质-皮质抑制结果反映了运动皮质中抑制性中间神经元的兴奋性,并且基底节的输出显著影响这种抑制,但躯体感觉系统或小脑的输出则不然。此外,当对照反应由I波产生时(即下行冲动由皮质脊髓束神经元的跨突触激活产生),皮质脊髓束或脊髓运动神经元的功能障碍不会影响配对磁刺激技术获得的结果。