Schneider L B, Libman R B, Kanner R
Department of Neurology, Long Island Jewish Medical Center, Albert Einstein College of Medicine, New Hyde Park, NY 11042, USA.
AJNR Am J Neuroradiol. 1996 Aug;17(7):1259-63.
To determine the utility of repeat brain imaging in patients with stroke.
We reviewed the medical records of 98 consecutive patients in whom stroke was diagnosed between January 1 and December 31, 1991. We noted the number of brain scans performed, the indications cited, and whether repeat imaging changed the therapeutic decisions or final diagnosis.
Ninety-eight patients underwent 221 procedures, with 123 repeat imaging studies (98 CT scans and 25 MR images). Sixteen patients had only one scan; 51 had two, and 31 had three or more. Indications for repeat imaging were explicitly documented in 62 (50%) of 123 repeated scans and inferred in another 41 (33%). In 20 (16%), no definite indication could be determined. Indications included lack of acute abnormal imaging findings on the initial scan (n = 48, 39%); compliance with stroke research protocol (n = 11, 9%). In none of the 82 patients did the repeated scan change the diagnosis; therapy was changed in only two (2%) of 82 patients (aspirin was discontinued).
Repeat imaging in patients rarely results in changes in the initial diagnosis or the therapeutic plan; indications for repeat imaging are frequently not clearly stated; in certain groups of patients with stroke, repeat imaging may not be useful.
确定对中风患者进行重复脑部成像检查的作用。
我们回顾了1991年1月1日至12月31日期间连续诊断为中风的98例患者的病历。我们记录了脑部扫描的次数、给出的检查指征,以及重复成像检查是否改变了治疗决策或最终诊断结果。
98例患者接受了221次检查,其中有123次重复成像检查(98次CT扫描和25次磁共振成像)。16例患者仅进行了一次扫描;51例进行了两次扫描,31例进行了三次或更多次扫描。在123次重复扫描中,62次(50%)明确记录了重复成像的检查指征,另外41次(33%)可推断出检查指征。20次(16%)无法确定明确的检查指征。检查指征包括初次扫描时未发现急性异常影像学表现(n = 48,39%);符合中风研究方案(n = 11,9%)。在82例患者中,重复扫描均未改变诊断结果;82例患者中只有2例(2%)的治疗方案发生了改变(停用了阿司匹林)。
对中风患者进行重复成像检查很少会改变初始诊断或治疗方案;重复成像检查的指征常常未明确说明;在某些中风患者群体中,重复成像检查可能并无用处。