Pavlik A, Csépai D, Hidas P, Bánóczy A
National Institute for Sports Medicine, Department of Sports Surgery, Budapest, Hungary.
Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc. 1996;4(2):116-20. doi: 10.1007/BF01477264.
Recurrent anterior shoulder instability and the restoration of sports ability after surgery are common problems, especially among professional athletes. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the rate, level and time of returning to sports activity activity after Bankart procedure in anterior shoulder instability in high level athletes. From 1992-1994 61 patients suffering from recurrent anterior shoulder instability were operated on open Bankart procedure, 44 out of 61 were professional athletes. There were 7 handball, 7 basketball, 6 football, 2 waterpolo and 1 baseball player and 4 wrestlers, 2 weight-lifters, 2 boxers, 3 bicyclists, 2 motorists, 2 swimmers, 2 sailors, 2 kayakers and 2 skiers. The mean duration of instability was 19.1 months (3-72) before operation. 29 patients had posttraumatic recurrent anterior dislocation and 15 patients had posttraumatic anterior subluxations. The average number of redislocations was 4.4, ranging from 2 to 11. At the follow-up examination the patients were tested clinically for instability using the special score created by Walch and Duplay and the Constant functional score. We measured the strength of the rotator cuff by Kintrex isokinetic device from the 10th postoperative week. 35 out of 44 professional athletes could be followed-up. The average follow-up period was 14.2 months, from 6 to 31. 88% of the patients were able to return to sports participation, 66% on the previous level and 22% on a lower level. 12% of the patients finished their professional sports career. The mean rehabilitation period was 5.8 months, the average period of full restoration of sports ability was 9.3 months. Similar results were documented with the Constant score and the Walch-Duplay test (88% excellent or good, 12% fair). The main reason for the inability to continue sports activity was some pain during extreme abduction and external rotation of the arm and recurrent sensations of subluxation (3 cases). Based on the results of the follow-up examinations an early diagnosis is paramount followed by timely surgical intervention to restore anatomical integrity in proven cases of shoulder instability in professional athletes. The open Bankart procedure is preferred giving excellent functional results and providing good chances for the athletes to return to their previous sports level.
复发性肩关节前脱位以及手术后运动能力的恢复是常见问题,在职业运动员中尤为如此。本研究的目的是评估高水平运动员肩前不稳定行Bankart手术后恢复运动活动的比率、水平和时间。1992年至1994年,61例复发性肩关节前脱位患者接受了开放性Bankart手术,其中44例为职业运动员。包括7名手球运动员、7名篮球运动员、6名足球运动员、2名水球运动员、1名棒球运动员、4名摔跤运动员、2名举重运动员、2名拳击手、3名自行车运动员、2名摩托车运动员、2名游泳运动员、2名水手、2名皮划艇运动员和2名滑雪运动员。术前不稳定的平均持续时间为19.1个月(3至72个月)。29例为创伤后复发性前脱位,15例为创伤后前半脱位。再脱位的平均次数为4.4次,范围为2至11次。在随访检查中,使用Walch和Duplay创建的特殊评分以及Constant功能评分对患者进行临床不稳定测试。从术后第10周开始,我们使用Kintrex等速装置测量肩袖肌力。44名职业运动员中有35名可以进行随访。平均随访期为14.2个月,范围为6至31个月。88%的患者能够恢复运动参与,66%恢复到之前的水平,22%恢复到较低水平。12%的患者结束了他们的职业运动生涯。平均康复期为5.8个月,运动能力完全恢复的平均时间为9.3个月。Constant评分和Walch-Duplay测试也记录了类似的结果(88%为优或良,12%为中)。无法继续进行体育活动的主要原因是手臂极度外展和外旋时出现一些疼痛以及反复出现半脱位感(3例)。根据随访检查结果,早期诊断至关重要,随后在职业运动员确诊为肩关节不稳定的情况下及时进行手术干预以恢复解剖完整性。开放性Bankart手术是首选,其功能效果极佳,为运动员恢复到之前的运动水平提供了良好机会。