Singh S, Evans L, Datta D, Gaines P, Beard J D
Sheffield Vascular Institute, Northern General Hospital, U.K.
Eur J Vasc Endovasc Surg. 1996 Oct;12(3):359-62. doi: 10.1016/s1078-5884(96)80257-7.
One hundred and fifty consecutive patients presenting with limb-threatening ischaemia were studied prospectively to determine treatment and rehabilitation costs in the first year. Limb salvage was attempted in 104 (69%) patients but failed in 13%. Mortality at 1 year was 27%. The cost of treatment, inpatient stay, occupational therapy, physiotherapy, convalescence, disablement services, home adaptations, home care, district nursing, transportation and outpatient visits were determined for each patient. The patients were classified according to their presentation and initial treatment into five groups (number of patients) whose median management costs (interquartile range) for 12 months were: Gp 1 (23 - Revascularisation for acute ischaemia = 3970 pounds (2984-5511) Gp 2 (29) - Angioplasty for critical ischaemia = 6611 pounds (3630-10,200) Gp 3 (52) - Reconstruction for critical ischaemia = 6766 pounds (4337-9677) Gp 4 (34) - Primary amputation = 10,162 pounds (7894-13,026) Gp 5 (12) - Primary bilateral amputations = 13,848 pounds (11,440-18,056) At 1 year, there was no significant difference in the cost of managing a patient with a critically ischaemic limb by angioplasty or surgical reconstruction. The cost of revascularisation for acute ischaemia was comparatively low because these patients required minimal rehabilitation. The median cost of managing a patient following amputation was almost twice that of successful limb salvage justifying an aggressive revascularisation policy. However, justification of such a policy on economic grounds requires salvage failure episode to be minimised as they increase costs considerably.
对150例出现肢体威胁性缺血的连续患者进行了前瞻性研究,以确定第一年的治疗和康复费用。104例(69%)患者尝试进行保肢治疗,但13%失败。1年时的死亡率为27%。确定了每位患者的治疗费用、住院时间、职业治疗、物理治疗、康复、残疾服务、家庭改造、家庭护理、社区护理、交通和门诊就诊费用。根据患者的表现和初始治疗将患者分为五组(患者数量),其12个月的管理费用中位数(四分位间距)为:第1组(23例 - 急性缺血血管重建)= 3970英镑(2984 - 5511英镑);第2组(29例 - 严重缺血血管成形术)= 6611英镑(3630 - 10200英镑);第3组(52例 - 严重缺血重建)= 6766英镑(4337 - 9677英镑);第4组(34例 - 一期截肢)= 10162英镑(7894 - 13026英镑);第5组(12例 - 一期双侧截肢)= 13848英镑(11440 - 18056英镑)。1年时,通过血管成形术或手术重建治疗严重缺血肢体患者的费用没有显著差异。急性缺血血管重建的费用相对较低,因为这些患者所需的康复最少。截肢后管理患者的费用中位数几乎是成功保肢费用的两倍,这证明了积极的血管重建政策的合理性。然而,基于经济理由证明这种政策的合理性需要将保肢失败事件降至最低,因为它们会大幅增加成本。