el-Masri H A, Thomas R S, Sabados G R, Phillips J K, Constan A A, Benjamin S A, Andersen M E, Mehendale H M, Yang R S
Department of Environmental Health, Colorado State University, Fort Collins 80523, USA.
Arch Toxicol. 1996;70(11):704-13. doi: 10.1007/s002040050331.
Carbon tetrachloride (CCl4) lethality in Sprague-Dawley rats is greatly amplified by pretreatment of Kepone (decachlorooctahydro-1,3,2-metheno-2H-cyclobuta[cd] pentalen-2-one). The increase in lethality was attributed to the obstruction of liver regenerative processes. These processes are essential for restoring the liver to its full functional capacity following injury by CCl4. Based on the available mechanistic information on Kepone/CCl4 interaction, a physiologically based pharmacokinetic/pharmacodynamic (PBPK/PD) model was constructed where the following effects of Kepone on CCl4 toxicity are incorporated: (1) inhibition of mitosis; (2) reduction of repair mechanism of hepatocellular injury; (3) suppression of phagocytosis. The PBPK/PD model provided computer simulation consistent with previously published time-course results of hepatotoxicity (i.e., pyknotic, injured and mitotic cells) of CCl4 with or without Kepone. As a further verification of this model, the computer simulations were also consistent with exhalation kinetic data for rats injected with different intraperitoneal (i.p.) doses of CCl4 in our laboratory. Subsequently, the PBPK/PD model, coupled with Monte Carlo simulation, was used to predict lethalities of rats treated with CCl4 alone and CCl4 in combination with Kepone. The experimental lethality studies performed in our laboratories were as follows: Sprague-Dawley rats were given either control diet or diet containing 10 ppm Kepone for 15 days. On day 16, rats in the Kepone treated group were given i.p. doses of 0, 10, 50, and 100 microliters/kg CCl4 (n = 9) while control rats were exposed to 0, 100, 1000, 3000, and 6000 microliters/kg CCl4 (n = 9). Lethality was observed at the 1000 (1/9), 3000 (4/9), and 6000 (8/9) microliters/kg doses for the control group and at the 50 (4/9) and 100 (8/9) microliters/kg for the treated group. Based on Monte Carlo simulation, which was used to run electronically 1000 lethality experiments for each dosing situation, the LD50 estimates for CCl4 toxicity with and without Kepone pretreatment were 47 and 2890 microliters/kg, respectively. Monte Carlo simulation coupled with the PBPK/PD model produced lethality rates which were not significantly different from the observed mortality, with the exception of CCl4 at very high doses (e.g., 6000 microliters/kg, p = 0.014). Deviation at very high doses of the predicted mortality from the observed may be attributed to extrahepatic systemic toxicities of CCl4, or solvent effects on tissues at high concentrations, which were not presently included in the model. Our modeling and experimental results verified the earlier findings of Mehendale (1990) for the 67-fold amplification of CCl4 lethality in the presence of Kepone. However, much of this amplification of CCl4 lethality with Kepone pretreatment was probably due to pharmacokinetic factors, because when target tissue dose (i.e., model estimated amount of CCl4 metabolites) was used to evaluate lethality, this amplification was reduced to 4-fold.
在斯普拉格-道利大鼠中,开蓬(十氯八氢-1,3,2-亚甲基-2H-环丁烷[cd]戊搭烯-2-酮)预处理会极大地增强四氯化碳(CCl4)的致死性。致死性增加归因于肝脏再生过程受阻。这些过程对于CCl4损伤后肝脏恢复其全部功能能力至关重要。基于现有的关于开蓬/CCl4相互作用的机制信息,构建了一个基于生理学的药代动力学/药效学(PBPK/PD)模型,其中纳入了开蓬对CCl4毒性的以下影响:(1)抑制有丝分裂;(2)降低肝细胞损伤的修复机制;(3)抑制吞噬作用。该PBPK/PD模型提供的计算机模拟结果与先前发表的有无开蓬情况下CCl4肝毒性(即固缩、受损和有丝分裂细胞)的时间进程结果一致。作为对该模型的进一步验证,计算机模拟结果也与我们实验室中给大鼠腹腔注射不同剂量CCl4后的呼气动力学数据一致。随后,将PBPK/PD模型与蒙特卡洛模拟相结合,用于预测单独用CCl4处理以及CCl4与开蓬联合处理的大鼠的致死率。我们实验室进行的实验性致死率研究如下:给斯普拉格-道利大鼠喂食对照饮食或含10 ppm开蓬的饮食15天。在第16天,给开蓬处理组的大鼠腹腔注射0、10、50和100微升/千克的CCl4(n = 9),而对照大鼠暴露于0、100、1000、3000和6000微升/千克的CCl4(n = 9)。对照组在1000(1/9)、3000(4/9)和6000(8/9)微升/千克剂量下观察到致死现象,处理组在50(4/9)和100(8/9)微升/千克剂量下观察到致死现象。基于蒙特卡洛模拟,针对每种给药情况进行了1000次电子致死率实验,结果显示,有无开蓬预处理时CCl4毒性的半数致死剂量(LD50)估计值分别为47和2890微升/千克。蒙特卡洛模拟与PBPK/PD模型相结合得出的致死率与观察到的死亡率没有显著差异,但CCl4高剂量(如6000微升/千克,p = 0.014)情况除外。预测死亡率在非常高剂量时与观察结果的偏差可能归因于CCl4的肝外全身毒性,或高浓度下溶剂对组织的影响,目前这些因素未包含在模型中。我们的建模和实验结果证实了梅亨德尔(1990年)早期的发现,即在有开蓬存在的情况下CCl4致死性放大了67倍。然而,开蓬预处理导致的CCl4致死性的这种放大很大程度上可能归因于药代动力学因素,因为当使用靶组织剂量(即模型估计的CCl4代谢物量)来评估致死性时,这种放大降低到了4倍。