Aloia J F, Vaswani A, Yeh J K, Flaster E
Department of Medicine, Winthrop-University Hospital, 259 First Street, Mineola, New York 11501, USA.
Calcif Tissue Int. 1996 Dec;59(6):415-23. doi: 10.1007/BF00369203.
Models of involutional bone loss and strategies for the prevention of osteoporosis have been developed for white women. Black women have higher bone densities than white women, but as the black population ages there will be an increasingly higher population of black women with osteoporosis. Strategies should be developed to reduce the risk of black women for fragility fractures. Dual energy X-ray absorptiometry measurements of the total body, femur, spine, and radius were performed on 503 healthy black and white women aged 20-80 years. Indices of bone turnover, the calcitrophic hormones, and radioisotope calcium absorption efficiency were also measured to compare the mechanisms of bone loss.The black women had higher BMD values at every site tested than the white women throughout the adult life cycle. Black women have a higher peak bone mass and a slightly slower rate of adult bone loss from the femur and spine, which are skeletal sites comprised predominantly of trabecular bone. Indices of bone turnover are lower in black women as are serum calcidiol levels and urinary calcium excretion. Serum calcitriol and parathyroid hormone levels are higher in black women and calcium absorption efficiency is the same in black and white women, but dietary calcium intake is lower in black women. Black and white women have a similar pattern of bone loss, with substantial bone loss from the femur and spine prior to menopause and an accelerated bone loss from the total skeleton and radius after menopause. The higher values for bone density in black women as compared with white women are caused by a higher peak bone mass and a slower rate of loss from skeletal sites comprised predominantly of trabecular bone. Low-risk strategies to enhance peak bone mass and to lower bone loss, such as calcium and vitamin D augmentation of the diet, should be examined for black women. The risk vs. benefits of hormonal replacement therapy should be determined, especially in older women.
针对白人女性,已经建立了绝经后骨质流失模型和预防骨质疏松症的策略。黑人女性的骨密度高于白人女性,但随着黑人人口老龄化,患骨质疏松症的黑人女性数量将越来越多。应制定策略以降低黑人女性发生脆性骨折的风险。对503名年龄在20至80岁之间的健康黑人和白人女性进行了全身、股骨、脊柱和桡骨的双能X线吸收测定。还测量了骨转换指标、钙营养激素和放射性同位素钙吸收效率,以比较骨质流失的机制。在整个成年生命周期中,黑人女性在每个测试部位的骨密度值均高于白人女性。黑人女性的骨峰值较高,股骨和脊柱的成人骨质流失速度略慢,而股骨和脊柱主要由小梁骨组成。黑人女性的骨转换指标较低,血清骨化二醇水平和尿钙排泄量也较低。黑人女性的血清骨化三醇和甲状旁腺激素水平较高,黑人和白人女性的钙吸收效率相同,但黑人女性的膳食钙摄入量较低。黑人和白人女性的骨质流失模式相似,绝经前股骨和脊柱有大量骨质流失,绝经后全身骨骼和桡骨的骨质流失加速。与白人女性相比,黑人女性较高的骨密度值是由较高的骨峰值和主要由小梁骨组成的骨骼部位较慢的流失速度所致。应研究针对黑人女性的低风险策略,如增加饮食中的钙和维生素D以提高骨峰值并减少骨质流失。应确定激素替代疗法的风险与益处,尤其是在老年女性中。