Gillespie N D, Brett C T, Morrison W G, Pringle S D
Department of Cardiology, Ninewells Hospital, Dundee, United Kingdom.
J Accid Emerg Med. 1996 Nov;13(6):395-7. doi: 10.1136/emj.13.6.395.
To assess the ability of a cohort of junior hospital doctors to interpret ECGs which have immediate clinical relevance and influence subsequent management of patients.
57 junior hospital doctors were interviewed and asked to complete a standard questionnaire which included eight ECGs for interpretation and a supplementary question relating to the administration of thrombolytic treatment. Each doctor was assessed over a 48 h period while they performed their daily clinical duties.
The major abnormality of anterior myocardial infarction was recognised by almost all doctors. There was difficulty in the interpretation of posterior myocardial infarction and second degree heart block. Most myocardial infarctions would have been given satisfactory thrombolysis, but there was a reluctance to use this treatment in patients with posterior myocardial infarction and left bundle brach block. A few patients without myocardial infarction would have received thrombolytic treatment.
There is varying ability among junior hospital doctors in the interpretation of the emergency electrocardiogram. The results are of concern as poor interpretation of the ECG can result in inappropriate management. As a result of the findings of this study it is proposed to introduce more formal training in the interpretation of clinically relevant ECG abnormalities for junior hospital doctors.
评估一批 junior 医院医生解读具有直接临床相关性且会影响患者后续治疗的心电图的能力。
对 57 名 junior 医院医生进行访谈,并要求他们完成一份标准问卷,其中包括八份用于解读的心电图以及一个与溶栓治疗给药相关的补充问题。在每位医生履行日常临床职责的 48 小时期间对其进行评估。
几乎所有医生都能识别前壁心肌梗死的主要异常。后壁心肌梗死和二度房室传导阻滞的解读存在困难。大多数心肌梗死患者本可接受满意的溶栓治疗,但对于后壁心肌梗死和左束支传导阻滞患者,医生不太愿意使用这种治疗方法。少数无心肌梗死的患者也会接受溶栓治疗。
junior 医院医生解读急诊心电图的能力参差不齐。由于心电图解读不佳可能导致治疗不当,这些结果令人担忧。基于本研究的结果,建议为 junior 医院医生引入更多关于解读具有临床相关性心电图异常的正规培训。