Shiono H
Department of Legal Medicine, Asahikawa Medical College, Japan.
Nihon Hoigaku Zasshi. 1996 Oct;50(5):320-30.
We performed personal identification by DNA polymorphism using forensic specimens. DNA was purified by the potassium iodine method instead of the phenol extraction method. When DNA is amplified by PCR, there are inhibitors of PCR such as melanin in hairs or blood and inorganic salts in bone. This problem was solved by the potassium iodine method. The genotype of the ABO blood groups could be determined by the polymerase chain reaction-restriction fragment length polymorphism (PCR-RFLP) method in all 29 old blood-stain specimens (obtained 11 months-15 years before) and 14 fingerprint specimens on a glass plate. In sexual assaults against women, one key to identifying the suspect is ABO phenotyping or the typing of other polymorphic markers of the seminal fluid in the victim's vagina. However, ABO phenotyping is frequently unsuccessful, since mixtures of fluids cannot be separated to be subjected to conventional methods for the detection of antibody or antigen material. We therefore studied ABO blood group genotyping of sperm DNA isolated from contaminating vaginal fluid by the PCR-RFLP method. Seminal samples of genotypes OO, AO, BO and AB were experimentally mixed with vaginal fluid (OO, AO, BO and AB), and were successfully separated and genotyped by this method. In practice, we also separated and genotyped the seminal DNA of suspects from contaminated postcoital vaginal fluid obtained in 4 sexual assaults. These forensic samples were easily separated and completely genotyped. This reliable ABO genotyping method by PCR-RFLP, using separated sperm DNA, should be of value in forensic identification in sexual assaults. We attempted sex and individual identifications of several forensic specimens by detecting various sex chromosome-specific sequences by the polymerase chain reaction (PCR) method. The specimens were 30 blood stains that were attached to gauze and stored 11 months-15 years (15 males, 14 females and 1 of unknown gender) and 10 bleached white bones (8-about 10000 years after death). Of the known 29 blood stains, the sex determination rate was the highest by DYZ-1 (amplified DNA fragment = 149bp, about 3000 copies on Y chromosome) recombinated with DXZ-1 (28 of the 29 samples) although 27 samples could be determined by DYZ-1 (amplified DNA fragment = 1000bp, about 3000 copies on Y chromosome) recombinated with DXZ-1. The sex determination rate was relatively low by DYZ-3 (amplified DNA fragment = 170bp, about 100 copies on Y chromosome) recombinated with DXZ-1 (23 of the 29 samples). The sex determination rate by two single locus markers, PAB or Amelogenin was markedly low (7 and 9 of 29 samples, respectively). The sex determination rate by the 27H39 locus was 27 of the 29 samples; 14 of the 15 male were determined (A = 186bp, 1; B = 190bp, 7; C = 194bp, 5; D = 198bp, 1; E = 202bp, 0). One unknown gender could be identified as male by multiple locus markers, but could not be identified by any single locus markers except for the 27H39 locus. Of the 10 bleached white bone specimens, 9 could be determined by the combination of DYZ-1 and DXZ-1, but the results of determination were inconsistent with the anthropological characteristics in 3 cases. The 27H39 locus showed polymorphism in 4 of the 6 anthropologically male beached bones. Studies on a new microsatellite on the Y chromosome are needed for evaluation of polymorphism on the Y chromosome because it is not necessary to consider the alleles from the female in the paternity test in male children or female-derived elements in sexual delict, and there is a distance between the alleles using 27H39 alone. In this study, We evaluated the allele distribution of DYS384, DYS388, DYS389, DYS390, DYS391, DYS392, and DYS393, in Japanese subjects and found the usefulness of DYS384 and DYS390. Future studies on personal identification by DNA polymorephism will mainly evaluate short tandem repeat (STR).
我们使用法医样本通过DNA多态性进行个人识别。DNA采用碘化钾法而非酚抽提法进行纯化。当通过聚合酶链反应(PCR)扩增DNA时,存在PCR抑制剂,如毛发或血液中的黑色素以及骨骼中的无机盐。碘化钾法解决了这个问题。通过聚合酶链反应 - 限制性片段长度多态性(PCR - RFLP)方法能够在所有29份陈旧血迹样本(采集于11个月至15年前)以及14份玻璃平板上的指纹样本中确定ABO血型的基因型。在针对女性的性侵犯案件中,识别嫌疑人的一个关键是对受害者阴道内精液的ABO血型进行表型分析或对其他多态性标记进行分型。然而,ABO血型表型分析常常不成功,因为混合液体无法分离以采用传统方法检测抗体或抗原物质。因此,我们研究了通过PCR - RFLP方法对从污染的阴道液中分离出的精子DNA进行ABO血型基因分型。将基因型为OO、AO、BO和AB的精液样本与阴道液(OO、AO、BO和AB)进行实验性混合,并通过该方法成功分离并进行基因分型。在实际操作中,我们还对4起性侵犯案件中获得的污染性交后阴道液中的嫌疑人精液DNA进行了分离和基因分型。这些法医样本易于分离并完全进行基因分型。这种通过PCR - RFLP对分离出的精子DNA进行可靠的ABO基因分型方法在性侵犯案件的法医鉴定中应具有重要价值。我们尝试通过聚合酶链反应(PCR)方法检测各种性染色体特异性序列来对多个法医样本进行性别和个体识别。样本包括30份附着在纱布上并保存了11个月至15年的血迹(15名男性、14名女性和1名性别不明者)以及10块漂白的白骨(死后约8至10000年)。在已知的29份血迹中,与DXZ - 1重组的DYZ - 1(扩增DNA片段 = 149bp,Y染色体上约3000个拷贝)的性别判定率最高(29个样本中有28个),尽管27个样本可通过与DXZ - 1重组的DYZ - 1(扩增DNA片段 = 1000bp,Y染色体上约3000个拷贝)进行判定。与DXZ - 1重组的DYZ - 3(扩增DNA片段 = 170bp,Y染色体上约100个拷贝)的性别判定率相对较低(29个样本中有23个)。两个单一位点标记PAB或牙釉蛋白的性别判定率明显较低(分别为29个样本中的7个和9个)。27H39位点的性别判定率为29个样本中的27个;15名男性中的14名被判定(A = 186bp,1个;B = 190bp,7个;C = 194bp,5个;D = 198bp,1个;E = 202bp,0个)。一名性别不明者可通过多位点标记被鉴定为男性,但除27H39位点外,任何单一位点标记均无法鉴定。在10份漂白白骨样本中,9份可通过DYZ - 1和DXZ - 1的组合进行判定,但在3例中判定结果与人类学特征不一致。在6份人类学判定为男性的漂白白骨中,27H39位点在4份中表现出多态性。由于在男性儿童的亲子鉴定中无需考虑来自女性的等位基因或性犯罪中女性来源的成分,且仅使用27H39时等位基因之间存在距离,因此需要对Y染色体上的新微卫星进行研究以评估Y染色体上的多态性。在本研究中,我们评估了日本受试者中DYS384、DYS388、DYS389、DYS39A、DYS391、DYS'92和DYS393的等位基因分布,发现DYS384和DYS390具有实用性。未来通过DNA多态性进行个人识别的研究将主要评估短串联重复序列(STR)。