Woydt M, Krone A, Becker G, Schmidt K, Roggendorf W, Roosen K
Department of Neurosurgery, University of Würzburg, Federal Republic of Germany.
Acta Neurochir (Wien). 1996;138(12):1391-8. doi: 10.1007/BF01411117.
The aim of this study was to evaluate whether intra-operative ultrasound (= IOUS) is a suitable tool to detect residual tumour tissue after gross total resection in supratentorial gliomas. During a period of 18 months 45 patients with supratentorial gliomas (38 high-grade and 9 low-grade, according to the WHO-grading system [42]) were operated on. A series of 78 biopsies was taken from the resection cavity under continuous sonographic control at the end of surgery. Gross total tumour resection was intended in 34 patients (= 76%). The biopsy specimens were matched with the sonographic features at each biopsy site. The sonographic appearance of the resection margins were classified into 2 groups: (1) Irregular hyperechoic areas extending from the cavity into the iso-echogenic brain tissue and (2) a dense small (< or = 3 mm in diameter) rather regular hyperechoic rim surrounding the resection cavity. 47 out of 53 biopsies taken from hyperechoic areas (group I) (36 high-grade/11 low-grade) revealed solid tumour tissue (= 89%). 34 (= 72%) of these 47 areas were microscopically assessed as inconspicuous by the surgeon. 6 samples (4 high-grade/2 low-grade) contained tumour infiltration zone. 25 biopsies (23 high-grade/2 low-grade) taken from the hyperechoic rim [group 2] were diagnosed as follows: Normal brain tissue in 11, tumour infiltration zone in 8 and solid tumour tissue in 6 cases. Of 34 cases with "gross total removal" according to the surgeon's assessment 25 showed sonographic signs of residual tumour tissue, which was confirmed histologically as solid tumour tissue in 22 of these cases. It is concluded, that IOUS following resection of supratentorial gliomas can detect residual tumour tissue with high specificity and thus improve gross total resection. However, a thin hyperechoic rim surrounding the resection cavity (less than 3 mm in diameter) is a non-specific finding, which can mask thin residual tumour layers and therefore needs further evaluation of its nature.
本研究的目的是评估术中超声(IOUS)是否是检测幕上胶质瘤全切除术后残留肿瘤组织的合适工具。在18个月的时间里,对45例幕上胶质瘤患者(根据世界卫生组织分级系统[42],38例高级别和9例低级别)进行了手术。手术结束时,在连续超声控制下从切除腔取了一系列78份活检标本。34例患者(76%)旨在进行肿瘤全切除。将活检标本与每个活检部位的超声特征进行匹配。切除边缘的超声表现分为两组:(1)从腔延伸至等回声脑组织的不规则高回声区;(2)围绕切除腔的致密小(直径≤3 mm)且较为规则的高回声边缘。从高回声区(第一组)取的53份活检标本中有47份(36例高级别/11例低级别)显示为实体肿瘤组织(89%)。外科医生在显微镜下评估这47个区域中的34个(72%)为不明显。6份样本(4例高级别/2例低级别)含有肿瘤浸润区。从高回声边缘(第二组)取的25份活检标本(23例高级别/2例低级别)诊断如下:11例为正常脑组织,8例为肿瘤浸润区,6例为实体肿瘤组织。在外科医生评估为“全切除”的34例病例中,25例显示有残留肿瘤组织的超声征象,其中22例经组织学证实为实体肿瘤组织。得出的结论是,幕上胶质瘤切除术后的术中超声能够以高特异性检测残留肿瘤组织,从而提高全切除率。然而,围绕切除腔的薄高回声边缘(直径小于3 mm)是一个非特异性发现,可能掩盖薄的残留肿瘤层,因此需要进一步评估其性质。