Ford J M, Stenning S P, Boote D J, Counsell R, Falk S J, Flavin A, Laurence V M, Bleehen N M
University Department and MRC Unit of Clinical Oncology and Radiotherapeutics, Addenbrookes Hospital, Cambridge, UK.
Clin Oncol (R Coll Radiol). 1997;9(1):20-4. doi: 10.1016/s0936-6555(97)80053-2.
Thirty-two patients prospectively identified as having poor prognosis high grade glioma, with a MRC prognostic score >25, were treated with a short palliative course of radiotherapy. A total dose of 36 Gy in 12 fractions was given to the tumour, including oedema and a 2 cm margin, using parallel pair fields prescribed to the midplane with MV photons. Twenty-eight patients completed treatment as planned, while four failed to complete treatment because of clinical deterioration or death. The median survival for the whole group was 16 weeks, with seven patients surviving for more than 6 months. Approximately two-thirds of the surviving patients remained at home after the completion of treatment. A matched case-control comparison with data from patients in previous MRC studies who had received a 6-week course of treatment shows that, for this group of patients, survival is similar (hazard ratio 1.0; 95% confidence interval (CI) 0.57-1.74). The 95% CI for the difference in median survival time excludes a reduction of more than 7 weeks with the 36 Gy course. This shortened radiotherapy regimen may therefore be satisfactory for most poor prognosis patients. However, patients with performance status 3 gained little benefit from treatment, and it is suggested that this group should have a trial period of assessment at home prior to a decision on treatment.
32例经前瞻性确定为预后不良的高级别胶质瘤患者,其医学研究委员会(MRC)预后评分>25,接受了短程姑息性放疗。使用兆伏光子对中平面进行平行对野照射,给予肿瘤包括水肿区及2 cm边界在内的总剂量36 Gy,分12次给予。28例患者按计划完成治疗,4例因临床病情恶化或死亡未能完成治疗。全组患者的中位生存期为16周,7例患者存活超过6个月。约三分之二的存活患者在完成治疗后仍在家中。与医学研究委员会以往研究中接受6周疗程治疗的患者数据进行匹配病例对照比较显示,对于这组患者,生存期相似(风险比1.0;95%置信区间(CI)0.57 - 1.74)。36 Gy疗程的中位生存时间差异的95% CI排除了生存期缩短超过7周的情况。因此,这种缩短的放疗方案对大多数预后不良的患者可能是令人满意的。然而,体能状态为3级的患者从治疗中获益甚微,建议该组患者在决定治疗前在家中进行一段评估期。