Shukla S, Patel B, Chitnis D S
Department of Microbiology & Immunology, Choithram Hospital & Research Centre, Indore.
Indian J Med Res. 1997 Feb;105:53-7.
A reappraisal of the Widal test was made for its diagnostic utility in typhoid fever in an endemic area of Central India. The significant basal antibody level in the normal population based on 1200 voluntary/relative blood donors at the cut-off titre of 80 or above was observed in 13.83 and 8.0 per cent for 'O' and 'H' antigens of Salmonella typhi respectively. A retrospective study (1991-1995) over 138 bacteriologically proven cases of typhoid showed a positivity of 64.49 and 78.26 per cent respectively for 'O' and 'H' antibodies at the titre of 80 or above and 44.2 and 63.04 per cent at the titre of 160 and above. The retrospective data also showed a greater positivity (46.41%) in 1991 which decreased to 25 per cent in 1995 and appeared to follow the incidence of multi drug resistant S. typhi over the period. The detection of 'H' antibodies is no less important than the 'O' antibodies in the present study. Our data bring out the diagnostic limitations of Widal test done on single samples collected in the early phase of illness (4-10 days) from patients suspected to have typhoid in an endemic area of Central India.
对维达试验在印度中部一个伤寒流行地区伤寒诊断中的应用价值进行了重新评估。以80及以上的临界滴度为标准,在1200名自愿/亲属献血者的正常人群中,分别观察到伤寒沙门氏菌“O”和“H”抗原的显著基础抗体水平为13.83%和8.0%。一项对138例经细菌学证实的伤寒病例的回顾性研究(1991 - 1995年)显示,滴度在80及以上时,“O”和“H”抗体的阳性率分别为64.49%和78.26%;滴度在160及以上时,阳性率分别为44.2%和63.04%。回顾性数据还显示,1991年的阳性率更高(46.41%),到1995年降至25%,且在此期间似乎与多重耐药伤寒沙门氏菌的发病率相关。在本研究中,“H”抗体的检测与“O”抗体同样重要。我们的数据揭示了在印度中部伤寒流行地区,对疑似伤寒患者在疾病早期(4 - 10天)采集的单一样本进行维达试验的诊断局限性。