von Meyer L, Hänseler E, Lardet G, Scholer A, Sieghart W
Institut für Rechtsmedizin, München, Germany.
Eur J Clin Chem Clin Biochem. 1997 Feb;35(2):133-40.
In accordance with the guidelines of the European Committee for Clinical Laboratory Standards (ECCLS), the performance of the Abbott AxSYM Abused Drugs assays were evaluated and compared with the results provided by the following systems: Syva Emit d.a.u./Roche Cobas Mira S Plus, Abbott TDx and ADx, Syva Emit d.a.u./Syva ETS Plus, Syva Emit II/Hitachi 717 and Roche Abuscreen OnLine/Roche Cobas Mira S Plus. The test analytes, cannabinoids, cocaine metabolites, opiates, benzodiazepines and barbiturates, were each investigated in three laboratories on different systems. The imprecision of all systems in the series and from day to day was good, with CVs less than 5% or 10%, respectively. The AxSYM calibration curves were stable for 3-4 months and none of the systems displayed any shift in the results of the analyses within one day or any faults caused by sample contamination. Within the framework of this study, a total of 1860 urine samples were investigated; 741 results were positive. All results which remained discrepant between AxSYM and the comparison systems after repeated analysis (n = 17) were subjected to further investigation using a reference method, with the exception of one barbiturate and two benzodiazepine samples. An additional test criterion was the practicability of the systems investigated and the versatility of the software. During this evaluation, the results provided by the Abbott AxSYM were excellent and were fully in line with the manufacturer's claims. The reliability of the FPIA technology that has been the subject of frequent investigation was also convincing during this evaluation. The possibility of semi-quantitative determination, the stability of the calibration curves, the ability to process an emergency sample without delay and its high suitability to routine operations are the convincing benefits offered by this system.
根据欧洲临床实验室标准委员会(ECCLS)的指南,对雅培AxSYM滥用药物检测方法的性能进行了评估,并与以下系统提供的结果进行了比较:Syva Emit d.a.u./罗氏Cobas Mira S Plus、雅培TDx和ADx、Syva Emit d.a.u./Syva ETS Plus、Syva Emit II/日立717以及罗氏Abuscreen OnLine/罗氏Cobas Mira S Plus。测试分析物包括大麻素、可卡因代谢物、阿片类药物、苯二氮卓类药物和巴比妥类药物,分别在三个实验室使用不同系统进行了研究。该系列中所有系统的日内和日间不精密度良好,变异系数分别小于5%或10%。AxSYM校准曲线在3至4个月内保持稳定,所有系统在一天内的分析结果均未出现任何偏移,也未出现因样品污染导致的任何故障。在本研究框架内,共对1860份尿液样本进行了调查;741份结果呈阳性。除一份巴比妥类药物样本和两份苯二氮卓类药物样本外,对AxSYM与比较系统经重复分析后仍存在差异的所有结果(n = 17)均采用参考方法进行了进一步调查。另一个测试标准是所研究系统的实用性和软件的通用性。在此次评估中,雅培AxSYM提供的结果非常出色,完全符合制造商的声明。在此次评估中,经常受到研究的荧光偏振免疫分析(FPIA)技术的可靠性也令人信服。半定量测定的可能性、校准曲线的稳定性、及时处理急诊样本的能力以及对常规操作的高度适用性是该系统令人信服的优点。