Wirfält A K, Jeffery R W
Malmö Diet Cancer Study, University of Lund, Sweden.
J Am Diet Assoc. 1997 Mar;97(3):272-9. doi: 10.1016/s0002-8223(97)00071-0.
This study explored the usefulness of cluster analysis in identifying food choice patterns of three groups of adults in relation to their energy intake.
Food frequency data were converted to percentage of total energy from 38 food groups and entered into a cluster analysis procedure. Subjects in the emerging food group patterns were compared in terms of weight status, demographics, and the nutrition composition of their usual diet.
Data were collected as part of three studies in two US metropolitan areas using identical protocols. Participants were university employees (103 women and 99 men) who volunteered for a reliability study of health behavior questionnaires and moderately obese volunteers (223 women and 101 men) to two weight-loss studies who were recruited by newspaper advertisements.
Subjects were clustered according to food energy sources using the FASTCLUS procedure in the Statistical Analysis System. One-way analysis of variance and chi 2 analysis were then performed to compared the weight status, nutrient intakes, and demographics of the food patterns.
Six food pattern clusters were identified. Subjects in the two clusters associated with high consumption of pastry and meat had significantly higher fat intakes (P = .0001). Subjects in two other clusters, those associated with high intake of skim milk and a broad distribution of energy sources had significantly higher micronutrient levels (P = .0001). Body mass index and the distribution of gender were also significantly different across clusters.
The success of cluster analysis in identifying dietary exposure categories with unique demographic and nutritional correlates suggests that the approach may be useful in epidemiologic studies that examine conditions such as obesity, and in the design of nutrition interventions.
本研究探讨聚类分析在识别三组成年人与能量摄入相关的食物选择模式方面的实用性。
食物频率数据被转换为来自38个食物组的总能量百分比,并进入聚类分析程序。对新出现的食物组模式中的受试者在体重状况、人口统计学特征以及其日常饮食的营养成分方面进行比较。
数据是作为美国两个大都市地区的三项研究的一部分收集的,采用相同的方案。参与者包括大学雇员(103名女性和99名男性),他们自愿参加健康行为问卷的可靠性研究,以及通过报纸广告招募的中度肥胖志愿者(223名女性和101名男性),参与两项减肥研究。
使用统计分析系统中的FASTCLUS程序根据食物能量来源对受试者进行聚类。然后进行单因素方差分析和卡方分析,以比较食物模式的体重状况、营养素摄入量和人口统计学特征。
识别出六种食物模式聚类。与糕点和肉类高消费量相关的两个聚类中的受试者脂肪摄入量显著更高(P = 0.0001)。另外两个聚类中的受试者,即与脱脂牛奶高摄入量和能量来源广泛分布相关的受试者,其微量营养素水平显著更高(P = 0.0001)。聚类之间的体重指数和性别分布也存在显著差异。
聚类分析成功地识别出具有独特人口统计学和营养相关性的饮食暴露类别,这表明该方法可能在研究肥胖等疾病的流行病学研究以及营养干预设计中有用。