Jason D R, Lantz P E, Preisser J S
Department of Pathology, Bowman Gray School of Medicine, Winston-Salem, NC, USA.
J Forensic Sci. 1997 Mar;42(2):270-5.
We mailed survey questionnaires to a random sample of medicolegal offices throughout the USA. The survey asked how many forensic pathologists were used, their American Board of Pathology forensic examination (Board) status, how many autopsies they performed, and, if payment were fee-for-service, what fees were paid for medicolegal autopsies. Response rate was 61%, with 188 offices returning questionnaires. The average fee, was $518 with a standard error of $27. The number of fee-for-service autopsies was split evenly between Board qualified and Board ineligible pathologists, accounting for about one-third of medicolegal autopsies nationwide. Although smaller offices used more pathologists ineligible for forensic Boards, they paid a premium for such qualification. Larger offices used more forensic Board qualified pathologists, but paid them less than those ineligible to take the examination! Overall there was no significant premium paid for Board qualification. The average fee paid is far less than the published estimates of the cost of an autopsy. The low fees paid may reflect: (1) the value of the teaching experience supplied to medical students and/or residents; (2) pathologists performing medico-legal examinations as community service; and (3) the lower marginal cost of additional autopsies.
我们向美国各地的法医办公室随机抽取的样本邮寄了调查问卷。该调查询问了所使用的法医病理学家的数量、他们在美国病理学会法医考试(委员会)中的状态、他们进行的尸检数量,以及如果是按服务收费,法医尸检的收费是多少。回复率为61%,有188个办公室返回了问卷。平均费用为518美元,标准误差为27美元。按服务收费的尸检数量在委员会合格和委员会不合格的病理学家之间平均分配,约占全国法医尸检的三分之一。虽然较小的办公室使用了更多不符合法医委员会资格的病理学家,但他们为这种资格支付了额外费用。较大的办公室使用了更多法医委员会合格的病理学家,但支付给他们的费用却比那些没有资格参加考试的人少!总体而言,委员会资格并没有显著的额外费用。支付的平均费用远低于公布的尸检成本估计。支付的低费用可能反映了:(1)为医学生和/或住院医生提供的教学经验的价值;(2)病理学家将进行法医检查作为社区服务;(3)额外尸检的较低边际成本。