McConnachie G, Carr E G
State of Washington Division of Developmental Disabilities, USA.
Behav Modif. 1997 Apr;21(2):123-58. doi: 10.1177/01454455970212001.
Maintenance of behavior change has been considered a crucial, through largely unrealized, goal of behavioral interventions. One often overlooked factor is that before interventions can be successful and durable, the intervention protocol must be implemented as planned. This study investigated the effects of child behavior problems on the maintenance of intervention fidelity by teachers across two intervention protocols: escape extinction and functional communication training. A high rate of behavior problems during escape extinction appeared to punish teachers' efforts, and fidelity deteriorated. In contrast, there was a low rate of behavior problems during functional communication training. Teachers maintained high protocol fidelity and those sessions were less stressful and more productive. We propose that intervention protocols can be differentiated by the costs associated with implementing them faithfully. Protocols designed to be user friendly will be more likely to produce high fidelity, and therefore, durable intervention gains.
行为改变的维持一直被视为行为干预的一个关键目标,尽管在很大程度上尚未实现。一个经常被忽视的因素是,在干预能够成功且持久之前,干预方案必须按计划实施。本研究调查了儿童行为问题对教师在两种干预方案(逃避消退和功能性沟通训练)中维持干预保真度的影响。在逃避消退过程中出现的高行为问题发生率似乎对教师的努力起到了惩罚作用,保真度下降。相比之下,在功能性沟通训练过程中行为问题发生率较低。教师维持了较高的方案保真度,并且这些课程压力较小且效率更高。我们提出,可以根据忠实地实施干预方案所涉及的成本来区分干预方案。设计得便于使用的方案更有可能产生高保真度,从而带来持久的干预效果。