Thadani U
University of Oklahoma, Health Sciences Center, Oklahoma City 73104, USA.
Cardiovasc Drugs Ther. 1997 Jan;10(6):735-42. doi: 10.1007/BF00053031.
Vascular tolerance develops rapidly in isolated vascular strips exposed to millimolar concentrations of nitroglycerin. Several mechanisms, including depletion of sulfhydryl groups, reduced biotransformation of nitrates to NO or nitrosothiols, oxygen free radical injury, and downregulation of a membrane-bound enzyme or a nitrate receptor, have been proposed, but the exact mechanism responsible for in-vitro tolerance remains unknown. In-vivo tolerance of the beneficial effects of nitrates on hemodynamics, myocardial ischemia, and exercise performance develops rapidly. It has been suggested, but remains to be proven, that development of venous tolerance and not arterial tolerance is responsible for the attenuation of nitrate effects during long-term nitrate therapy. Several mechanisms, including neurohormonal activation, depletion of sulfhdryl groups, and the shift of fluid from the extravascular to intravascular compartment have been implicated. However, the use of agents to counteract these mechanisms (ACE inhibitors, sulfhydryl donors, diuretics) has produced conflicting results. Thus, at present the mechanism responsible for in vivo tolerance to nitrates remains unknown. Both in vitro and in vivo vascular tolerance to nitrates can be prevented or minimized by providing nitrate-free or low-nitrate intervals. However, during nitrate-free periods, rebound phenomena (rest angina in patients with ischemic heart disease or a deterioration in exercise performance prior to the renewal of the morning dose in patients with stable angina) remain a clinical concern. When treating patients with stable angina pectoris, it must be recognized that none of the nitrate preparations or formulations can provide round-the-clock antianginal or antiischemic prophylaxis. In these patients, beneficial antianginal and antiischemic effects of nitrates for 10-14 hours during the daytime can be maintained by using formulations and dosing regimens that avoid or minimize the development of tolerance (standard formulation of isosorbide-5-mononitrate, 20 mg in the morning and 7 hours later; slow-release formulation of isosorbide-5-mononitrate, 120-240 mg once a day; or nitroglycerin patch delivering 0.6 nitroglycerin per hour for 10-12 hours each day). Only the patch on and off treatment is associated with nitrate rebound. Although intermittent nitrate therapy is not associated with the development of tolerance, this strategy cannot be recommended for treating unstable angina because rebound angina during nitrate-free periods complicates clinical decision making. In the acute phase of unstable angina, continuous treatment with intravenous nitroglycerin is recommended because it permits rapid up- or down-titration. Tolerance towards antianginal and antiischemic effects does develop in a substantial number of patients with 24 hours, but this can be overridden by dose escalation and restoration of the therapeutic effectiveness of nitroglycerin. Tolerance towards the beneficial effects of nitrates on hemodynamics and on exercise performance also develops rapidly during continuous or long-term nitrate therapy, and for these reasons nitrates are not used as first-line therapy to treat chronic heart failure. In combination with hydralazine, high-dose isosorbide dinitrate (30-40 mg four times a day) improves survival, but this combination therapy is inferior to ACE inhibitors.
在暴露于毫摩尔浓度硝酸甘油的离体血管条中,血管耐受性迅速形成。已经提出了几种机制,包括巯基耗竭、硝酸盐向一氧化氮或亚硝基硫醇的生物转化减少、氧自由基损伤以及膜结合酶或硝酸盐受体的下调,但体外耐受性的确切机制仍然未知。硝酸盐对血流动力学、心肌缺血和运动能力的有益作用在体内的耐受性迅速形成。有人提出,但仍有待证实,静脉耐受性而非动脉耐受性的形成是长期硝酸盐治疗期间硝酸盐作用减弱的原因。涉及了几种机制,包括神经激素激活、巯基耗竭以及液体从血管外间隙向血管内间隙的转移。然而,使用药物来对抗这些机制(血管紧张素转换酶抑制剂、巯基供体、利尿剂)产生了相互矛盾的结果。因此,目前体内对硝酸盐耐受性的机制仍然未知。通过提供无硝酸盐或低硝酸盐间隔期,可以预防或最小化体外和体内对硝酸盐的血管耐受性。然而,在无硝酸盐期间,反弹现象(缺血性心脏病患者的静息性心绞痛或稳定型心绞痛患者在早晨剂量恢复前运动能力的恶化)仍然是一个临床问题。在治疗稳定型心绞痛患者时,必须认识到没有一种硝酸盐制剂或剂型能够提供全天候的抗心绞痛或抗缺血预防。在这些患者中,通过使用避免或最小化耐受性形成的剂型和给药方案(5-单硝酸异山梨酯标准剂型,早上20毫克,7小时后服用;5-单硝酸异山梨酯缓释剂型,每天120-240毫克;或每天10-12小时每小时释放0.6毫克硝酸甘油的硝酸甘油贴片),可以在白天维持硝酸盐10-14小时的有益抗心绞痛和抗缺血作用。只有贴片的开和关治疗与硝酸盐反弹有关。虽然间歇性硝酸盐治疗与耐受性的形成无关,但这种策略不推荐用于治疗不稳定型心绞痛,因为无硝酸盐期间的反弹性心绞痛会使临床决策复杂化。在不稳定型心绞痛的急性期,建议持续静脉输注硝酸甘油治疗,因为它允许快速上调或下调剂量。相当多的患者在24小时内确实会产生对抗心绞痛和抗缺血作用的耐受性,但这可以通过增加剂量和恢复硝酸甘油的治疗效果来克服。在持续或长期硝酸盐治疗期间,对硝酸盐对血流动力学和运动能力的有益作用的耐受性也会迅速形成,因此硝酸盐不被用作治疗慢性心力衰竭的心衰一线治疗药物。与肼屈嗪联合使用时,高剂量的二硝酸异山梨酯(每天4次,每次30-40毫克)可提高生存率,但这种联合治疗不如血管紧张素转换酶抑制剂。