Claeys L G, Horsch S
Department of Vascular Surgery, General Hospital Cologne-Porz, Academic Teaching Hospital, University of Cologne, Germany.
Int Angiol. 1996 Dec;15(4):344-9.
This study was designed to test the hypothesis that initial TcPO2 helps predict clinical outcome in vascular patients treated with spinal cord stimulation. A randomized-controlled study with one year follow-up was made in 86 Fontaine stage IV patients with endstage peripheral arterial occlusive disease (PAOD) undergoing 21 day intravenous prostaglandin E1 (PGE1) therapy for nonhealing ulcers.
All patients had arteriosclerosis, 13 also diabetes mellitus. Entry criteria included: non-reconstructible PAOD as proven by intra-arterial angiography or patient condition, ankle systolic pressure < 50 mmHg, severe rest pain despite analgetic medication, and presence of nonhealing foot ulcers or dry gangrene. One week after the start of PGE1 therapy, patients were randomized into receiving SCS plus PGE1 (n = 45 patients), or just PGE1 (n = 41 patients). Follow-up examinations were done at 1, 3, 6 and 12 months. BASELINE: There were no significant differences between both groups in the following: age, sex distribution, ischemic skin lesions, risk factors and several key group mean physiological values including ankle systolic pressure, ankle/brachial ratio (ABI) and foot TcPO2. The SCS group had more prior vascular leg surgeries (1.77 vs 1.58 per patient). RESULTS AT 12 MONTHS: There was significantly better total healing of foot ulcers in the SCS-group (69 vs 17%; p < 0.0001). Significantly more SCS-patients achieved an outcome of Fontaine stage II (claudication pain, no rest pain or lesions) (40 vs 10%, p = 0.0014). The frequency of minor and major amputations was not different, respectively 13 vs 15% and 16 vs 20%. The mean ABI at 12 months of the treated limb of the SCS-patients was not significantly greater. Foot TcPO2 increased significantly for the SCS-group (+213 vs -2%; p < 0.0001). Patients in either group whose TcPO2 rose to 26.0 +/- 8.6 mmHg on average were able to heal ulcers or toe amputation wounds. PGE1-patients had temporary TcPO2 elevations of about 33% on average but this was gone by six months. SCS-patients had steady increases in TcPO2, and maintained them at 12 months. Among the SCS-patients, those with baseline TcPO2 < = 10 mmHg had significantly less success at 12 months, this was not observed for the OMT-patients. The regional perfusion index increased significantly, 187 vs 0%; p < 0.001.
Spinal cord stimulation appears to provide a major benefit for lesion improvement in stage IV patients with non-reconstructible PAOD. Patients with an initial TcPO2 > 10 mmHg will respond better to the stimulation therapy. With pain relief and ulcer healing quality of life improved. Effects on limb salvage do not appear.
本研究旨在验证以下假设,即初始经皮氧分压(TcPO2)有助于预测接受脊髓刺激治疗的血管疾病患者的临床结局。对86例处于Fontaine IV期的终末期外周动脉闭塞性疾病(PAOD)患者进行了一项为期一年随访的随机对照研究,这些患者因溃疡不愈合正在接受为期21天的静脉注射前列腺素E1(PGE1)治疗。
所有患者均患有动脉硬化,其中13例还患有糖尿病。入选标准包括:经动脉血管造影或患者病情证实为不可重建的PAOD、踝部收缩压<50 mmHg、尽管使用了镇痛药仍有严重静息痛、存在溃疡不愈合的足部溃疡或干性坏疽。PGE1治疗开始一周后,患者被随机分为接受脊髓刺激(SCS)加PGE1组(n = 45例患者)或仅接受PGE1组(n = 41例患者)。在1、3、6和12个月时进行随访检查。基线情况:两组在以下方面无显著差异:年龄、性别分布、缺血性皮肤病变、危险因素以及包括踝部收缩压、踝臂指数(ABI)和足部TcPO2在内的几个关键组平均生理值。SCS组既往进行血管腿部手术的次数更多(每位患者1.77次对1.58次)。12个月时的结果:SCS组足部溃疡的总体愈合情况明显更好(69%对17%;p < 0.0001)。更多接受SCS治疗的患者达到Fontaine II期结局(间歇性跛行疼痛,无静息痛或病变)(40%对10%,p = 0.0014)。小截肢和大截肢的频率没有差异,分别为13%对15%和16%对20%。SCS患者治疗肢体在12个月时的平均ABI没有显著升高。SCS组足部TcPO2显著升高(+213对 -2%;p < 0.0001)。两组中平均TcPO2升至26.0±8.6 mmHg的患者能够愈合溃疡或趾截肢伤口。接受PGE1治疗的患者平均TcPO2有暂时升高,约为33%,但6个月后消失。SCS患者的TcPO2持续升高,并在12个月时保持。在SCS患者中,基线TcPO2<=10 mmHg的患者在12个月时的成功率显著较低,而在接受其他治疗(OMT)的患者中未观察到这种情况。区域灌注指数显著升高,为187%对0%;p < 0.001。
脊髓刺激似乎为不可重建的PAOD IV期患者的病变改善带来了主要益处。初始TcPO2>10 mmHg的患者对刺激治疗的反应更好。随着疼痛缓解和溃疡愈合,生活质量得到改善。对肢体保全似乎没有影响。