Cottraux J
Psychiatre des hôpitaux, Unité de traitement de l'Anxiété, Hôpital neurologique, Lyon.
Encephale. 1996 Dec;22 Spec No 5:54-60.
This general presentation reviews briefly the various psychotherapies proposed for panic attacks and agoraphobia treatment. Cognitive-behaviour therapy (CBT) is the only validated therapy. Behavioural model of agoraphobia and cognitive model of panic attacks are detailed. The main techniques are described. The results of controlled studies and meta-analyses demonstrate that CBT represents an alternative to anxiolytics and antidepressants. CBT is a brief form of therapy (10-20 sessions) which has been compared with waiting list, placebo, relaxation, antidepressants, anxiolytics or supportive therapy. Four meta-analyses agree on that in vivo exposure is a core element of the treatment of panic attacks and agoraphobia. They demonstrate also that agoraphobia is more difficult to treat than panic attacks in which placebo effect is quite powerful. Cognitive therapy centered on panic attacks demonstrated a significant effectiveness in controlled studies. CBT facilitates benzodiazepines withdrawal. Combination of in vivo exposure with high doses of benzodiazepines is counter-productive in the long term. Controlled studies are favorable to the combination of CBT with imipramine, SSRI (paroxetine, fluvoxamine) or buspirone. But the positive effects of these combinations are only found in the short term. CBT possesses the advantage of stable long term effects.
本综述简要回顾了针对惊恐发作和广场恐惧症治疗所提出的各种心理疗法。认知行为疗法(CBT)是唯一经过验证的疗法。详细阐述了广场恐惧症的行为模型和惊恐发作的认知模型。描述了主要技术。对照研究和荟萃分析的结果表明,CBT是抗焦虑药和抗抑郁药的一种替代疗法。CBT是一种短期疗法(10 - 20次治疗),已与等待名单、安慰剂、放松疗法、抗抑郁药、抗焦虑药或支持性疗法进行了比较。四项荟萃分析一致认为,现场暴露是惊恐发作和广场恐惧症治疗的核心要素。它们还表明,广场恐惧症比安慰剂效应相当显著的惊恐发作更难治疗。以惊恐发作为中心的认知疗法在对照研究中显示出显著疗效。CBT有助于停用苯二氮䓬类药物。从长期来看,现场暴露与高剂量苯二氮䓬类药物联合使用会适得其反。对照研究支持CBT与丙咪嗪、选择性5-羟色胺再摄取抑制剂(帕罗西汀、氟伏沙明)或丁螺环酮联合使用。但这些联合使用的积极效果仅在短期内发现。CBT具有长期效果稳定的优势。