Graham B, McGregor K
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, University of Edinburgh.
Br J Gen Pract. 1997 Mar;47(416):170-2.
Demand for information regarding the cost-effectiveness of health care treatment options is growing. It is necessary to derive unit costs for services, such as general practice (GP) consultations, in order to inform the economic evaluation.
To review the literature, provide a description of the three key steps that should be followed in the costing process and to provide a method for updating costs calculated in previous years.
A literature search was carried out to identify references that specifically describe the cost of a consultation in general practice. A total of 20 references were extracted, categorized and reviewed. A cost-price index for health care goods was obtained from the British Medical Association and used to construct a table to allow rapid reference and updating of cost results. The costs reported in the literature were updated and compared.
Twenty published studies referring to the unit cost of a GP consultation were located in the searches. Half of these did not describe the methodology used to derive the costs; of those that did, less than half covered the necessary steps to derive unit costs. The cost of an average 10-minute consultation in 1995/96 figures was estimated to be 6.90 +/- 2.73 pounds.
Great variation exists regarding the methodology for costing a GP consultation. If the methods used are stated explicitly and incorporate the three steps described, then results obtained in previous years may be updated using the cost-price index as shown (Table 1). Interpretation in this area must be made with caution.
对于医疗保健治疗方案成本效益信息的需求日益增长。为了进行经济评估,有必要得出诸如全科医疗(GP)咨询等服务的单位成本。
回顾文献,描述成本核算过程应遵循的三个关键步骤,并提供一种更新前几年计算成本的方法。
进行文献检索,以确定专门描述全科医疗咨询成本的参考文献。共提取、分类和回顾了20篇参考文献。从英国医学协会获得医疗保健商品的成本价格指数,并用于构建一个表格,以便快速参考和更新成本结果。对文献中报告的成本进行了更新和比较。
在检索中找到了20项关于全科医疗咨询单位成本的已发表研究。其中一半没有描述得出成本所使用的方法;在描述了方法的研究中,不到一半涵盖了得出单位成本的必要步骤。1995/96年平均10分钟咨询的成本估计为6.90 +/- 2.73英镑。
全科医疗咨询成本核算方法存在很大差异。如果明确说明所使用的方法并包含所述的三个步骤,那么前几年获得的结果可以使用所示的成本价格指数进行更新(表1)。在这一领域的解释必须谨慎。