Zoppi J A, Pellicer E M, Sundblad A S
Department of Pathology, Hospital Privado de Comunidad, Mar del Plata, Argentina.
Acta Cytol. 1997 May-Jun;41(3):701-4. doi: 10.1159/000332688.
To compare the nuclear grade (NG) in cytologic material (CNG) obtained from breast fine needle aspiration biopsies (FNABs) with the NG observed in surgical biopsies (BNG) of the same tumors.
The study group consisted of 135 breast carcinomas with both FNAB and biopsy. Most of them were invasive ductal carcinomas. Cytologic aspirates and tissue sections were graded simultaneously by the three authors using a multiheaded microscope. Fisher's modification of Black's nuclear grading scheme was used.
There was agreement between CNG and BNG in 70.37% of tumors. The percentage coincidence was slightly greater for NG 3.
Nuclear grade can be easily established on FNAB. The lack of correlation (29.63%) may have been due to tumor heterogeneity and observer subjectivity when assigning nuclear grade.
比较从乳腺细针穿刺活检(FNAB)获得的细胞学材料中的核分级(CNG)与同一肿瘤手术活检(BNG)中观察到的核分级。
研究组由135例同时接受FNAB和活检的乳腺癌患者组成。其中大多数为浸润性导管癌。三位作者使用多头显微镜同时对细胞学吸出物和组织切片进行分级。采用Fisher对Black核分级方案的改良方法。
70.37%的肿瘤中CNG和BNG一致。NG 3的符合率略高。
FNAB上可轻松确定核分级。缺乏相关性(29.63%)可能是由于肿瘤异质性和核分级判定时观察者的主观性。