Steckel R J, Batra P, Johnson S, Zucker M, Sayre J, Goldin J, Lee M, Patel M, Morrison H
Department of Radiological Sciences, UCLA School of Medicine 90095-1721, USA.
AJR Am J Roentgenol. 1997 Jun;168(6):1409-13. doi: 10.2214/ajr.168.6.9168698.
New standards for hospital accreditation and health care reimbursement may require that faculty subspecialists be more available after regular working hours to supervise residents in academic radiology departments. We designed a receiver operating characteristic study to determine whether a thoracic radiologist who evaluated computed radiography (CR) images of the chest at a home-based teleradiology workstation could add significant value to a junior resident's interpretations of films within the hospital for acutely ill patients.
Using a hybrid cassette, we obtained analog chest films and CR images simultaneously for each of 252 acutely ill patients in the emergency department and in an intensive care unit. Interpretations of the analog films by three first-year residents were analyzed for 11 parameters deemed critical for patient management. Likewise, CR images of the same chest studies were viewed on a home teleradiology workstation by a faculty thoracic radiologist who analyzed the images for these 11 interpretive parameters. All interpretations by radiology residents and by the home-based thoracic radiologist were then compared with the interpretations of a consensus panel consisting of another thoracic radiologist and a full-time emergency department radiologist.
Analysis of the pooled results from the three junior residents as a group failed to show significant differences between their interpretations of chest films and the interpretations of CR images by a thoracic radiologist at a home workstation. However, we observed significant differences for several image interpretation parameters between individual residents and the home-based radiology subspecialist.
The data confirm that significant value can be added to the interpretations of chest films by individual junior residents when a home-based thoracic radiologist uses teleradiology to provide expert interpretations. Accordingly, it is reasonable to infer that on-line supervision by faculty subspecialists via teleradiology could be used to complement the scheduled visits that are being made now by individual faculty members of our institution to interpret films periodically with a radiology resident during overnight and weekend periods.
医院认证和医疗保健报销的新标准可能要求专科教员在正常工作时间之后能更方便地指导学术放射科的住院医师。我们设计了一项接受者操作特征研究,以确定在家中远程放射学工作站评估胸部计算机X线摄影(CR)图像的胸科放射科医生,是否能为医院内初级住院医师对急症患者胸片的解读增添显著价值。
我们使用混合暗盒,为急诊科和重症监护病房的252例急症患者同时获取模拟胸片和CR图像。分析了三名一年级住院医师对模拟胸片的解读,涉及11个对患者管理至关重要的参数。同样,一名胸科放射科教员在家庭远程放射学工作站查看相同胸部检查的CR图像,并分析这些图像的这11个解读参数。然后将放射科住院医师和在家的胸科放射科医生的所有解读与由另一名胸科放射科医生和一名急诊科全职放射科医生组成的共识小组的解读进行比较。
将三名初级住院医师的汇总结果作为一个整体进行分析,未发现他们对胸片的解读与在家工作站的胸科放射科医生对CR图像的解读之间存在显著差异。然而,我们观察到个别住院医师与在家的放射专科医生在几个图像解读参数上存在显著差异。
数据证实,当在家的胸科放射科医生使用远程放射学提供专家解读时,个别初级住院医师对胸片的解读可增添显著价值。因此,可以合理推断,专科教员通过远程放射学进行在线监督可用于补充我们机构的个别教员目前在夜间和周末定期与放射科住院医师一起解读片子的预定查房。