Hattis D
Marsh Institute Center for Technology, Environment, and Development, Clark University, Worcester, Massachusetts, USA.
Environ Health Perspect. 1996 Apr;104 Suppl 2(Suppl 2):381-90. doi: 10.1289/ehp.96104s2381.
The mathematical form for a dose-time-response model is ideally not just a convenience for summarizing or fitting a particular data set--it represents a hypothesis. The more this hypothesis reflects a mechanistically sophisticated view of the likely reality, the more it can lead to potentially informative validating or invalidating types of predictions about the results of real experiments and (in the long run) reasonably credible predictions outside the range of direct observations. This paper first reviews some distinctive features of the nervous system and neurotoxic responses and theoretically explores some basic quantitative implications of these features. Relationships are derived for how dose-response relationships for the inhibition of function should depend on the numbers of neurons in series or redundant parallel arrangements that are required or capable of performing the function. Previous work is reviewed in which some less nervous-system-specific features were the foci of quantitative risk-assessment modeling for specific neurotoxic end points. These include a) rates of repair of putatively reversible damage in the case of acrylamide; b) human interindividual variability in susceptibility to fetal/developmental effects in the case of methylmercury; and c) opportunities to use intermediate biomarkers to assist in integrated animal toxicological and epidemiologic investigations of the chronic cumulative risks posed by agents that contribute to neuronal loss with increasing age and pathology.
剂量-时间-反应模型的数学形式理想情况下不仅仅是为了方便总结或拟合特定数据集——它代表一种假设。这种假设越能反映对可能现实的复杂机制观点,就越能导致关于真实实验结果的潜在有信息价值的验证或证伪类型的预测,并且(从长远来看)在直接观察范围之外做出合理可信的预测。本文首先回顾神经系统和神经毒性反应的一些独特特征,并从理论上探讨这些特征的一些基本定量含义。推导了功能抑制的剂量-反应关系应如何取决于串联或冗余并联排列中执行该功能所需或能够执行该功能的神经元数量的关系。回顾了先前的工作,其中一些较少针对神经系统的特征是特定神经毒性终点定量风险评估建模的重点。这些包括:a)丙烯酰胺情况下假定可逆损伤的修复率;b)甲基汞情况下人类个体对胎儿/发育影响的易感性差异;c)利用中间生物标志物协助对随着年龄增长和病理变化导致神经元损失的物质所造成的慢性累积风险进行综合动物毒理学和流行病学调查的机会。