Smeets P M, Barnes D
Department of Psychology, Leiden University, Holland.
J Exp Child Psychol. 1997 Jul;66(1):64-84. doi: 10.1006/jecp.1997.2377.
This study examines whether trained and derived simple discriminations lead to conditional relations between discriminative stimuli of the same and opposite (S+, S-) functions. After being trained on an arbitrary X-Y task (X1-Y1, X2-Y2) and on two simple discrimination tasks (A1+/A2- and B1+/B2-), children (Experiment 1) and adults (Experiment 2) were tested on the formation of novel simple discriminations (A3+/A2- and B3+/B2-) and conditional stimulus relations between all directly and indirectly paired A stimuli and between all directly and indirectly paired B stimuli (A1-A2-A3, B1-B2-B3). Subjects who formed these sets also received A2-X1 and B1-X2 training followed by a series of probes to assess the formation of two five-member stimulus equivalence classes (A1-A2-A3-X1-Y1, B1-B2-B3-X2-Y2). A modest majority of the children matched the directly paired stimuli (A2-A1, B2-B1 and A1-A2, B1-B2; A2-A3, B2-B3 and A3-A2, B3-B2) with one another while only a few of them also matched the indirectly paired stimuli with one another (A1-A3, B1-B3 and A3-A1, B3-B1). Those who did also related all the A and B stimuli with the designated X and Y stimuli. By contrast, all normal adults matched all paired and conditionally linked stimuli with one another. Present findings and those of related studies on stimulus equivalence are discussed from a stimulus contiguity perspective.
本研究考察经过训练和推导得出的简单辨别是否会导致具有相同和相反(S+,S-)功能的辨别性刺激之间形成条件关系。在接受了一个任意的X - Y任务(X1 - Y1,X2 - Y2)以及两个简单辨别任务(A1+/A2-和B1+/B2-)的训练后,儿童(实验1)和成人(实验2)接受了关于新的简单辨别(A3+/A2-和B3+/B2-)的测试,以及所有直接和间接配对的A刺激之间和所有直接和间接配对的B刺激之间的条件刺激关系测试(A1 - A2 - A3,B1 - B2 - B3)。形成这些集合的受试者还接受了A2 - X1和B1 - X2训练,随后进行了一系列探测,以评估两个五成员刺激等价类(A1 - A2 - A3 - X1 - Y1,B1 - B2 - B3 - X2 - Y2)的形成。大多数儿童将直接配对的刺激(A2 - A1,B2 - B1以及A1 - A2,B1 - B2;A2 - A3,B2 - B3以及A3 - A2,B3 - B2)相互匹配,而只有少数儿童也将间接配对的刺激相互匹配(A1 - A3,B1 - B3以及A3 - A1,B3 - B1)。那些做到这一点的儿童还将所有A和B刺激与指定的X和Y刺激联系起来。相比之下,所有正常成年人都将所有配对和条件关联的刺激相互匹配。从刺激接近性的角度讨论了当前的研究结果以及相关的刺激等价性研究结果。